3 ms·
I worked with him for a while. The most frustrating part is that he wants Xanadu to be a closed-source, for-profit, 1988 style piece of capitalist software with
by kristopolous 11y ago
I worked with him for a while. The most frustrating part is that he wants Xanadu to be a closed-source, for-profit, 1988 style piece of capitalist software with potentially, maybe, open standards.
The content he wants to be DRM'd through micropayments and all for-profit with fine-tuned rights and fees for attributions etc.
Also things like multi-phasic design where you do 80% and then the other 20% is a non-starter. He wants a waterfall-model cathedral or nothing at all.
So I really wanted to work more with him but he couldn't get that no matter how awesome (it involves a file that maintains binary offset pointers to another file WITHOUT a source file that generates both so yes, you append to byte 1 and then you need to ROLL YOUR OWN tool to change the offsets in the offsets file - oh yeah, they're also in a binary format), because of it's systemic structure, he was effectually just proposing another proprietary locked-down format that won't go anywhere and was imposing a structure that will ONLY lead to one-off proof-of-concepts and prototypes.
Which is exactly what we've seen. For 50 years. I have a VM with demos in Java, TCL, and many other bygone languages written by people like myself. I remember saying:
"There's a deeper structural reason why the web uses HTML and not Microsoft DOC as its language."