5 ms·
I grew up very poor, this did not make me stupid and implying such is offensive. There are poor people who can work it out and there are those who simply are in
by donatj 11y ago
I grew up very poor, this did not make me stupid and implying such is offensive. There are poor people who can work it out and there are those who simply are incapable.
Knowing people that are still poor, including much of my own family, it is very obvious that they're unwilling to apply themselves. They give in to the easy quick fix, even when actively told not to and shown a better path. They are largely beyond help.
The people I know will make just as bad of decisions if given money. They are poor because they don't think about the future, they don't not think about the future because they're poor.
- indlebe 11y agoDr. Mike Gazzaniga has done some excellent research on free will (or the lack thereof). It's impossible to break from the path on which you are headed, however you are responsible. Something happened to you that set you on a better path than that of the poor folks with the lack of forward thinking abilities that you mention.
- wpietri 11y agoThat is a common view, but I don't think it's correct, and I don't think it's supported by the science. I also grew up poor, but having been in tech for decades, being well off is a shit-ton easier. When thing go wrong, I have a cushion that I didn't before. That gives me time to think, time to recover from trauma, time and patience to consider and plan. I would love to attribute my new circumstances to my enormous virtue. But honestly, I think it's more about having lucked into a career that happens to be a great match and also be highly rewarded. For those interested in the science how scarcity shapes cognition, this is a good book: http://scholar.harvard.edu/sendhil/scarcity http://scholar.harvard.edu/sendhil/scarcity For those unfamiliar with the experience of poverty, John Scalzi's piece "Being Poor" is evocative: http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ http://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ And unlike most sites, that one definitely benefits from reading the comments.
- fencepost 11y ago"Being poor is knowing exactly how much everything costs." There was a time when I could say exactly how much breakfast ingredients were per serving: oatmeal serving $0.xx; 2 eggs $0.20 (obviously not this year), 2 sausages $0.20 (frozen, buy when on sale for $1/box). I wasn't really constrained by those prices, but I was certainly sensitive enough with irregular customer payments to be well aware of them.
- wfo 11y agoScientific studies are not about you and your personal experiences. They are not about any one person. They are about trying to understand trends, general phenomena, and how humans tend to act under a variety of circumstances. You're an outlier, great. We get that you resent everyone who hasn't managed to pull themselves out of poverty but that's not what this article is about.
- WalterBright 11y agoHow does this compare with the 1800s, where tens of millions of people who arrived with nothing but a suitcase managed to move up into the middle class?
- djtriptych 11y agoYou may want to do more than zero research into how the middle class was created before joining this discussion. Hint: start with WW2
- NoClass 11y agoIf you did more that 1 second of research, you'd know the history of the middle class in the US starts in the early 1800s with the growth of manufacturing, not WWII. WWII was a huge boost for various reasons (women in the workforce, GI Bill), but it doesn't negate the parents point about the immigrants of the previous century.
- chongli 11y agoStart a bit earlier: with FDR and The New Deal.
- ctlby 11y agoThe persistence of this myth is truly remarkable. Consider that Veblen published "The Theory of the Leisure Class" in 1899. What we consider today the middle class was very much alive and booming by the end of the 19th century.
- Mikeb85 11y ago> I grew up very poor, this did not make me stupid and implying such is offensive. There's always outliers. You may be one. The point isn't that poor people are stupid, but that because of circumstance, they have 'overhead' which prevents them from being able to make the optimal decision.
- hoprocker 11y agoAgreed. I'm sure there are also some examples out there of people who, despite insurmountable privilege, managed to make all of the wrong decisions and end up on the streets.
- jonesb6 11y agoIt is possible that though you grew up poor, you still had advantages that allowed you to rise out of it that the vast majority of those in poverty did not? A mother who cared about your education and read to you? A teacher in high school who took you under their wing? A strong computer science program in you high school? A strong interest in computing among your friends, which transitioned over to you?
- Bjartr 11y ago>I grew up very poor, this did not make me stupid and implying such is offensive. It's not that being poor makes you stupid, it's that when you are poor you tend to more carefully consider the consequences of decisions involving finances out of habit, which takes time and effort. That's time and effort your brain could be spending doing other things. It says nothing about innate ability, only that using more resources for one task leaves less for other tasks. You could be a certified genius and this would still apply to you. How much the effect has on overall success is a completely different discussion and has no bearing on whether or not the effect exists in the first place. >it is very obvious that they're unwilling to apply themselves. >They give in to the easy quick fix, even when actively told not to and shown a better path. Would you be willing to consider alternate explanations why these things appear to be the way they are? >The people I know will make just as bad of decisions if given money. What if making good use of lots of money is a skill? A skill that takes learning to do well? What if certain patterns that affect a poor person result in the creation of habits that are really bad when you have lots of money? If either or both of those are even partly true, it makes a lot more sense why poor people have difficulty when given lots of money without being forced to ascribe it to their inherent goodness of character. >They are poor because they don't think about the future, they don't not think about the future because they're poor. Why must this be the only explanation? Is it really fair to generalize your own experiences with a handful of people over the millions of people dealing with poverty?
- mreiland 11y ago> Why must this be the only explanation? That was the reasoning the article gave as well, the only difference is the article tried to explain why that is.
- Riseed 11y agoBeing poor doesn't make you stupid any more than a runaway process makes a computer slow. But being poor consumes mental energy and time, approximately equivalent to a decrease of 13 IQ points[0], just as a runaway process will make the affected computer slower (regardless of how fast it would otherwise be). [0] http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/growing-up-poor-is-bad-for-your-brain http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/growing-up-poor-is-bad-for-...
- datashovel 11y agoI think it's natural for people who have never been given the benefit of the doubt to feel no responsibility to society for changing their ways. Someone has to be the bigger man / woman in order to break the cycle. EDIT: And keep in mind, this attitude is not just learned from experience. If enough generations have experienced these hardships I imagine it can become a culture that perpetuates itself among entire families. It's hard to argue they're wrong when you're brought up in it and have never experienced anything different.