4 ms·
Is 6 billion euro a large sum to invest on such a potentially game-changing project? How much does the US spend on coal, or solar, or wind each year?
by andrepd 11y ago
Is 6 billion euro a large sum to invest on such a potentially game-changing project? How much does the US spend on coal, or solar, or wind each year?
- epistasis 11y agoSpending that 6 billion euro on, say, lithium ion batteries would generate 40GWh of batteries at current prices, but would likely drive down the price drastically as a guaranteed market is established the learning rate on batteries increases. We're at the point with current technology that we have tremendous gains that can be had simply by scaling industry. We don't need one GigaFactory, we need 200 of them.
- XorNot 11y agoLithium ion batteries aren't an energy source.
- epistasis 11y agoWhich is why they are called batteries... I'm not sure what point you're trying to make by stating the obvious. So I'll just say that electrical storage is a key component of any carbon neutral renewable energy grid. And whether they're in cars or attached to wind turbines or solar panels, an investment of that size would generate great benefits for the technology in general in addition to the economic benefits.
- hannob 11y agoThe 6 billion is the original number. The real number is 15 billion + X with X largely unknown. That was my whole point: I find a project that is so dishonest about its real cost not trustworthy. Whether you consider that worth the price will largely depend on whether you believe it's game-changing. I don't.
- jacquesm 11y agoIt will be game-changing at any price, the first problem is to find a solution that works sustainable at the scales we are looking for, then we can look at the economics. I agree that that is the harder problem but I'd be more than happy if ITER or any other fusion project would get to > 1.
- jasonwatkinspdx 11y agoThe US has been spending about 8% of GDP on energy, or in very rough terms, around 1.2 trillion a year. So the 6 billion euros is actually pretty close to 1 year of the US's total energy spend.