4 ms·
ARM CPU's aren't really comparable to anything above the Intel's ATOM line in terms of benchmark performance, and raw real world applications still give x86 bas
by dogma1138 11y ago
ARM CPU's aren't really comparable to anything above the Intel's ATOM line in terms of benchmark performance, and raw real world applications still give x86 based CPU's a huge advantage.
http://www.computingcompendium.com/p/arm-vs-intel-benchmarks.html http://www.computingcompendium.com/p/arm-vs-intel-benchmarks...
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=nvidia_tegrak1_preview&num=1 http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=nvidia_te...
Allot of the "performance" of most of these SOC's actually comes from the GPU/DSP portion of the SOC rather than the pure CPU.
So far it seems that Intel's bet was correct it will take them just as much time to reduce x86 (Skylake/Core-M, Bay-Trail/Cherry Trail/Willow Trail) power consumption to ARM SOC levels as it would take ARM SOC's to come close to x86 performance, and Intel will still win at the end.
Keep in mind that in 2007-2008 Intel was very seriously considering licensing ARM and other technologies to compete in the ultra portable and mobile markets and we are all better off that it didn't do so.
Intel now has offerings which are better or comparable to ARM based SOC's without fragmenting the ARM ecosystem even further and with having another avenue of technologies and intellectual property to keep the competition going and to offer an alternative to ARM/RISC with both the ability to streamline transition and having a fall back option which is always needed.
An all ARM ecosystem is just as bad (or even worse since unlike x86 it doesn't guarantee compatibility) as a monopolized x86 one.
We should also be quite thankful to ARM and it's users as they have been the driving force behind much of Intel's work lately as AMD was not really offering competition since the old Athlon-X64 days.
The new Core-M7 offers 2 cores at a boost clock of 3.1ghz, and a 1ghz GPU and beat every ARM SOC out there in terms of performance especially in places where it actually counts while having a TDP of 4.5W which is comparable to high end SOC's like Apple's A9x/A8x and considerably lower than the NVIDIA high end offering although that one blows everything out of the water when it comes to graphical performance as it has desktop GPU core's in it.
- timthorn 11y agoThe server focussed SOCs shipping currently (none of which are listed in those benchmark links) can have much better performance than Atom. There's a broad spectrum of ARM cores for different markets, and different optimisations that can be applied to SoC design decisions to target a part at different markets.
- dogma1138 11y agoThe OP was talking about mobile not server SOC's but fine.... The server SOC's also have a power consumption several times greater. So if that's what you want lets look at the Xeon-D performance wise they are very competitive to Intel's discrete CPU's, and beat the AppliedMicro X-Gene 2.4 quite harshly... http://www.anandtech.com/show/9185/intel-xeon-d-review-performance-per-watt-server-soc-champion http://www.anandtech.com/show/9185/intel-xeon-d-review-perfo...
- rwmj 11y agoThe X-Gene 1 was a development platform designed to work out the software bugs (and it's also obsolete now, since it was first produced in 40nm in 2013). Obviously if you compare latest Intel SoC with some 2+ year old dev-kit, the latest Intel looks great! They should compare Xeon with Cavium ThunderX, X-Gene 2/3, AMD Seattle, Qualcomm's latest server SoC or the HiSilicon D0x. http://www.hotchips.org/wp-content/uploads/hc_archives/hc26/HC26-11-day1-epub/HC26.11-4-ARM-Servers-epub/HC26.11.430-X-Gene-Singh-AppMicro-HotChips-2014-v5.pdf http://www.hotchips.org/wp-content/uploads/hc_archives/hc26/... http://www.cavium.com/ThunderX_ARM_Processors.html http://www.cavium.com/ThunderX_ARM_Processors.html
- dogma1138 11y agoWell the Xeon-D 1540 sits just below the E5 in most benchmarks, unfortunately I can't conjure benchmarks out of think air, but you don't seem to be able to do so either (but for all accounts Cavium isn't shipping anything yet, all i could find are press releases that some one said they'll be building servers based on their SOC bot nothing else). I wasn't comparing anything, anantech was they compared an available Intel Xeon-D SOC against a commercially available HP micro-server that was launched 6 months prior so either HP chose to use an "obsolete development platform that was designed to work out software bugs" or that what was available for them at the time. Again I wasn't saying that ARM CPU's are bad, I was saying that anyone that is saying that they currently can beat Intel on either price/performance or performance/wattage across the board is delusional.
- rwmj 11y agoYou're only looking at 32 bit ARM CPUs. 64 bit ARM is quite literally a different beast, and (for example) the 48 core Cavium that I have access to at work[1] is easily comparable to an Intel Xeon. [1] https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2015/11/24/48-core-arm-64-bit-server/ https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2015/11/24/48-core-arm-64-bit-ser...
- dogma1138 11y agoNo I'm looking at consumer offerings just like the OP mentioned - mobile devices, but that's fine lets compare apples to apples then, but keep in mind that these aren't 4W devices either. http://www.anandtech.com/show/9185/intel-xeon-d-review-performance-per-watt-server-soc-champion http://www.anandtech.com/show/9185/intel-xeon-d-review-perfo...
- RockyMcNuts 11y agothose blog benchmarks are 2013 and 2014. current benchmarks linked in the blog post show ARM competitive with Core i5 (single-core) although not i7. http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/11/ipad-pro-review-mac-like-speed-with-all-the-virtues-and-limitations-of-ios/4/#h2 http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/11/ipad-pro-review-mac-lik... blog post also links to published reports saying Intel has 1,000 people working on a SOC for iPhone. http://venturebeat.com/2015/10/16/intel-has-1000-people-working-on-chips-for-the-iphone/ http://venturebeat.com/2015/10/16/intel-has-1000-people-work...
- dogma1138 11y agoARS isn't loading for me, yes the a9x is a monster chip especially as far graphics and synthetic benchmarks goes, try real world applications (quite hard to near impossible on Apple devices due to the closed ecosystem) including web server performance, video compression throttling and many more aspects and you'll see that's not the case. It's very competitive with Core-M devices for sure but sorry not sold out on it being competitive against Core-I devices on any level besides maybe graphical performance so far. As far as Intel making apple SOC's and? Intel is selling modems to Apple, and it wants to fab SOC's for them as well. Since Apple is fabless and Intel has the most advanced SC production line at the time it nailed 14nm and it's pushing for 10nm next year for launch in 2017 I don't see this being indicative of anything, Intel tested the water with ARM almost 8 years ago and it decided to continue with x86, and we've seen quite interesting things coming from them Core-M, Xeon-D, and even things like Intel Edison which showed that x86 can be scaled to pretty much every use at this time while still being very interesting and competitive in terms of both price, performance, and power consumption. We've been hearing this gloom and doom about "Wintel" for almost 2 decades now, linux is going to beat them, no wait apple power PC, no ARM, sigh it's getting old. Intel isn't going anywhere soon and it has enough resources to push through and their technology and where they can take it so far does not seem to be obsolete on any scale.
- josh2600 11y ago"Nailed 14nm". Lol. I guess maybe you missed all the news about Intel fubar'ing it's 14nm and having to order more 16nm capacity from TSMC to deal with the pain? http://techbuyersguru.com/hotdealsblog/tbg-commentary-intels-14nm-woes-and-the-future-of-cpu-tech/ http://techbuyersguru.com/hotdealsblog/tbg-commentary-intels... Intel might've once been unstoppable, but they're not perfect any more.
- scholia 11y ago> Keep in mind that in 2007-2008 Intel was very seriously considering licensing ARM and other technologies to compete in the ultra portable and mobile markets and we are all better off that it didn't do so. Actually, Intel sold a range of ARM chips from 1998-2006. It gained the DEC StrongARM design team when Compaq bought DEC and Compaq didn't want it. Intel then sold the XScale range of ARM chips, before deciding that x86-compatibility was the right way to go. That decision led to the Atom range. Intel sold its ARM operation to Marvel for $600 million. Intel still has an architecture license so it can design ARM chips if it wants.
- guelo 11y agoThen how come nobody in the Android ecosystem is able to build a successful device with Intel? Even after Qualcomm had a very bad ARM chip for the last 2 years and Apple is beating their pants off nobody, from Sony to LG to Samsung, is willing to go with Intel.
- AReallyGoodName 11y agoI think it's just the extra power options arm has. Scaling ARM speed just means writing to the PLL register of the CPU. Power usage is pretty much linear with frequency and being able to go to 3Mhz one core from 2Ghz quad via the OS is excellent. x86 now has dynamic core and frequency speeds but it's not OS driven, the CPU does it on its own. Understandable since you can't just add such features to the ever compatible x86. So x86 can't be forced to scale down by the OS which is helpful on a phone (screen off = user won't notice apps running slow). Nothing inherent to the power/performance of the cpu itself. It's just that arm can and does get extra power saving features tacked on as required.
- throwaway2048 11y agothis really isn't accurate, clock control of the processor via the OS has been possible on x86 for more than a decade.
- TheCondor 11y agoPackaging? Will Intel let you graft in parts from your partners or do you have to get it all from them?