3 ms·
> Only in the non-relativistic limit. That's only if use non-relativistic mass which you should not be doing anyway. In any case it's still proportional to mas
by ars 11y ago
> Only in the non-relativistic limit.
That's only if use non-relativistic mass which you should not be doing anyway. In any case it's still proportional to mass and velocity - the gamma factor does not change that.
> meaning the actual momentum of the object is a thousand to a million times what the non-relativistic formula would make you think.
You are missing parts of the interaction. Say it eats an atom - it has to accelerate that atom to the same relativistic velocity - meaning that new atom now has EXACTLY the same gamma as the black hole, and steals just as much momentum as if gamma was 1.
Or in other words the gamma factor is completely irrelevant for these calculations, it cancels out.
> it would need to absorb thousands or millions of times its starting mass to be slowed down to less than Earth escape velocity
As I've shown you, this is incorrect. It only needs to absorb mass similar to its own rest mass.
> And at its starting speed it would take less than a twentieth of a second to pass through the entire Earth.
That is also irrelevant. The only thing that matters is its "width", i.e. how many of the particles it interacts with does it eat.
- drdeca 11y agoIf the gamma is expressed in terms of velocity, wouldn't that suggest that the momentum isn't exactly proportional to velocity? Because otherwise you could say anything is proportional to velocity, but with another term which counteracts that factor? Also, I thought the view was shifting to using rest mass instead of relativistic mass but I might have that backwards.
- pdonis 11y ago> If the gamma is expressed in terms of velocity, wouldn't that suggest that the momentum isn't exactly proportional to velocity? Yes. At ultrarelativistic velocities, momentum can change a lot for a very, very small change in velocity, so the behavior is highly nonlinear.
- pdonis 11y ago> Say it eats an atom - it has to accelerate that atom to the same relativistic velocity Not quite the same, but almost, yes. The final velocity of the hole after it eats the atom will be equal to the velocity of the center of mass of the hole + atom before the atom is eaten. But if the hole has the rest mass of Mount Everest, the motion of the center of mass of the system will be almost the same as the motion of the hole, since the rest mass of Mount Everest is probably about 40 orders of magnitude larger than the rest mass of an atom. > meaning that new atom now has EXACTLY the same gamma as the black hole Yes. But this gamma will be slightly less than the gamma of the hole before it ate the atom. > and steals just as much momentum as if gamma was 1. I see what you're thinking, but it's still wrong; you haven't calculated the effect correctly. See below. > It only needs to absorb mass similar to its own rest mass. No. Say the hole starts out with rest mass M, and is moving at velocity v, where v is almost 1 (the speed of light), so the gamma factor is, say, 1000. Then the total momentum is about 1000M. Now the hole absorbs enough atoms to have rest mass 2M, and each atom is at rest before it's absorbed, so each atom contributes zero momentum to the total, so the total momentum is still 1000M after all the atoms are absorbed. That means the gamma factor is now (to a very good approximation) 500 (rest mass 2M times gamma of 500 times v approximately 1 gives momentum 1000M), which still corresponds to an ultrarelativistic velocity. For the velocity to be less than Earth escape velocity, the total momentum of 1000M would have to be carried by a hole with a rest mass of about 3 million M, since Earth escape velocity is about 1/3000 of the speed of light (11.2 km/s vs. 300,000 km/s)--i.e., we would have rest mass 3 million M times gamma of approximately 1 times v of 1/3000, to give total momentum 1000M. > That is also irrelevant. The only thing that matters is its "width", i.e. how many of the particles it interacts with does it eat. The cross section (what you are calling "width"--what fraction of particles encountered does the hole eat) will depend on the speed of the hole; the faster the hole is traveling, the lower the cross section will be.
- ars 11y ago> That means the gamma factor is now (to a very good approximation) 500 (rest mass 2M times gamma of 500 times v approximately 1 gives momentum 1000M), which still corresponds to an ultrarelativistic velocity. OK, I see your point. At those speeds a tremendous reduction in speed-energy (AKA relativistic mass) is only a small reduction in speed. > the faster the hole is traveling, the lower the cross section will be. At these masses gravitational attraction (that could pull in matter if given some time) is basically nil. I am assuming direct front-end collisions between the black hole and matter, so the speed doesn't make much difference. Although thinking about it, I suspect the cross section (event horizon radius) of a proton massed black hole would be smaller than a neutrino.
- pdonis 11y ago> I am assuming direct front-end collisions between the black hole and matter, so the speed doesn't make much difference. Ah, ok; yes, in this approximation (which I agree is a pretty good one--there is another subthread on this that I've been posting in), the number of particles eaten is basically the number of atoms that can be lined up end to end across the diameter of the Earth (in the worst case scenario where the hole flies straight down through the Earth). That number is about 10^17, which is many, many orders of magnitude less than the number of atoms in Mount Everest (the very rough back-of-the envelope number I come up with for that is 10^40). > I suspect the cross section (event horizon radius) of a proton massed black hole would be smaller than a neutrino. I thought the hole's mass was assumed to be about that of Mount Everest, at least for this discussion. The horizon radius of such a hole would be about 1.5 x 10^-14 meters, or about the size of a large atomic nucleus. I'm not sure we have a good number for the "size" of a neutrino.
- ars 11y ago> I thought the hole's mass was assumed to be about that of Mount Everest, at least for this discussion. There were two discussions at once - Mount Everest, and a particle from the LHC.
- 11y ago