3 ms·
We don't know what a black hole will do, we just guess. Normally I don't ask this sort of question, but are you a practicing physicist? If you are then this p
by nitrogen 11y ago
We don't know what a black hole will do, we just guess.
Normally I don't ask this sort of question, but are you a practicing physicist? If you are then this point is irrelevant. But if not, then we're all laymen/women here, and it's silly to accept the mathematical "guess" that says there might be tiny black holes but reject the proposed properties, when the same math that postulates their existence describes their likely properties.
You should really look into the history of science - it will give you some humility. At every age we thought we were at the pinnacle of science, only for later generations to find out things we never realized.
No doubt. I'm not questioning that. I'm saying it's presumptuous to pick and choose elements of a hypothesis without understanding the math behind it. If any of the participants in this thread are qualified to do so (clearly I am not), I'd love a link to your work on black holes. Otherwise, I maintain my original position.
- ars 11y agoThe math for hawking radiation is far less accepted than the math for black holes. You are making a mistake by giving them equal weight. Not that the math for black holes is all that well accepted in the first place - there are many holes in the math that quite clearly scream "we don't really know". For example a charged, or rapidly spinning singularity might be "naked" which breaks all theories and clearly shows how little we know about black holes. > but reject the proposed properties, when the same math that postulates their existence describes their likely properties. That isn't true though. It's completely different math. And Hawking radiation has a large information theory hole which tells us to be cautious - there is a gap in the theory, we don't actually know what will happen. Remember neither of these theories have ever been observed, it's all math and simulations, no observations. (Super massive objects have been observed, but not event horizons.)
- mamon 11y ago> Hawking radiation has a large information theory hole If you are referring to the fact that radiation brings back information from the inside of the black hole, which undermines notion of black hole being "event horizon", then there is one proposal to close this hole (it had been even submitted to HN recently): computational complexity. From what I understood this means that while in principle radiation leaks information from inside of the black hole, the computational effort needed to put that information together in its original form is too big to be possible to do in practice (at least before thermodynamical death of universe).