4 ms·
> it ceased to be about just speech and opinion, and instead became something quite vindictive and nasty. A few points to ponder (from a non-American): 1. It
by sangnoir 11y ago
> it ceased to be about just speech and opinion, and instead became something quite vindictive and nasty.
A few points to ponder (from a non-American):
1. It was a bad precedent. How would you feel about pro-lifers hounding a CEO out because of a donation?
2. His opinion is/was not extreme or unusual. About half of the American population share his views.
3. Is it reasonable to expect the full-range personal of views (and voting patterns) of a CEO to be agreeable to every employee?
My personal take is that the episode showed that no one has spine at Mozilla. Around the same time, people were raising concerns about Condoleezza Rice being on Dropbox's board; Dropbox's response was "we value her, she's not going anywhere" - and that was the end of it.
I shouldn't have to say this, since what I said should stand on it's own merit: but I disagree with Eich's politics. However I don't think that it had any bearing of his capability and execution as a CEO. If my boss is professional & courteous when dealing with me, I couldn't care less if he were a KKK Grand Dragon.
- byuu 11y ago> How would you feel about pro-lifers hounding a CEO out because of a donation? This is difficult to compare. A donation to keep an existing right versus a donation to take an existing right away. For these to compare, it would have to be a donation toward a proposition that stripped women of the right not to have an abortion, which is nonsensical. > His opinion is/was not extreme or unusual. That's a horrible justification. There used to be majority support for slavery, segregation, anti-miscegenation, etc. > Is it reasonable to expect the full-range personal of views (and voting patterns) of a CEO to be agreeable to every employee? Like I said, I didn't want to get into who should be able to say what when. But if it's free speech for Eich to make that donation, then it's definitely free speech for people to protest against him for making it as well. Again, no one forced him out. He resigned voluntarily. The people complaining held zero power in Mozilla. > If my boss is professional & courteous when dealing with me, I couldn't care less if he were a KKK Grand Dragon. Even if you were a black employee? I'm not sure I could be so magnanimous, but kudos to you for that :D
- sangnoir 11y agoFYI: I am a black employee, but as I said, not American. It goes without saying that I'm speaking only for myself. YMMV