14 ms·
How bad would it be if we accidentally made a black hole?
- rfjedwards 11y agoWhew!
- tdurden 11y agorelated: http://news.sciencemag.org/europe/2015/08/tiny-black-holes-could-trigger-collapse-universe-except-they-dont http://news.sciencemag.org/europe/2015/08/tiny-black-holes-c...
- Havoc 11y agoBeyond a certain level of screw-up there isn't anyone around to care anyway.
- maaku 11y agoThat's not a reason not to care in advance of trying something dangerous...
- idlewords 11y agoThe article briefly mentions the large amount of energy stored in the collider beams. In the LHC, "each unimpeded beam is capable of melting a 500-kilogram block of copper." This energy has to be dissipated in a few microseconds if something goes wrong in the collider. For the LHC, the solution is to heat a huge graphite cylinder to over 700 C. Not as cool as a black hole, but a pretty neat engineering challenge. http://spectrum.ieee.org/aerospace/astrophysics/cern-to-start-up-the-large-hadron-collider-now-heres-how-it-plans-to-stop-it http://spectrum.ieee.org/aerospace/astrophysics/cern-to-star...
- SeanDav 11y agoVery interesting - I wonder why they did not choose to run the beam through water to dissipate energy?
- SamReidHughes 11y agoDo you mean steam?
- jepler 11y agoGraphite stays solid at standard pressure up to 3900K (source: wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon) so you get ~3600K of ΔT from standard temperature of ~300K before you have to deal with a liquid or gas. Coupled with being denser than water (but having lower specific heat than liquid or solid water), my napkin is telling me you get about 10x the heat capacity in J/m³ with graphite instead of water.
- idlewords 11y agoThere's a technical discussion of using graphite vs. aluminum vs. copper in this paper: http://flash.desy.de/sites2009/site_vuvfel/content/e403/e1642/e1132/e1129/infoboxContent1791/fel2006-05.pdf http://flash.desy.de/sites2009/site_vuvfel/content/e403/e164... And a comparison of graphite vs. water schemes here: http://tesla.desy.de/new_pages/TESLA_Reports/2001/pdf_files/tesla2001-04.pdf http://tesla.desy.de/new_pages/TESLA_Reports/2001/pdf_files/...
- SeanDav 11y agoThanks for the links. I note that the graphite vs water scheme paper actually concludes that water cooling would be the preferred method.
- deelowe 11y agoYou'd need a pretty serious pressure vessel. I think time is a factor here.
- shasta 11y agoThe article makes it sound like a black hole with the mass of Everest wouldn't be scary, since it would only have strong attractive force within a few meters. But wouldn't it fall to the center of the earth, absorbing anything in its way and then wouldn't the earth fall into it? Seems like its lack of strength at a few meters isn't what makes it not-scary.
- XorNot 11y agoIt can only absorb matter at a rate limited by its event horizon surface area, and further limited by its ability to shear matter from outside the event horizon to fall into it. At the center of the earth, since its the gravitational locus of the planet, we wouldn't even notice it - while stuff would be falling in, the planet would still weigh the same and thus have the same surface gravity, and most of the planets material would resisit falling in by pressure against itself.
- 05 11y agoThis is all so very wrong: - it's all liquid at very high pressures, so the pressure guarantees a steady stream of new matter to feed to the hole - even if by some miracle there was a material strong enough to hold the pressure (and temperatures at the center) of the whole earth without buckling in (spoiler: there really isn't) creating a sphere filled with vacuum with the hole at the center, it wouldn't stay centered, because gravitational forces inside the cavity in such a configuration balance out, so the smallest disturbance would make the hole move towards the edge of that empty sphere, resulting in those super-strong walls getting pulled in as well
- abtinf 11y agoEarth's core is believed to be a solid ball of iron, not liquid.
- XorNot 11y agoThe earth's core is going to be spinning relative to the black hole. Of course a lot will fall in but any material on the outside will not make a straight line for the hole - its going to start picking up angular momentum, interacting and colliding with material which is trying to move directly toward the black hole and deflecting it. Remember anything which doesn't land on the event horizon is going to spiralling around and deflecting anything trying too. This is why blackholes glow in the X-ray in space and it would apply here too. Sure, matter will stream in at a constant rate - but there are real mechanical limits.
- evanpw 11y agoRelated article: http://phys.org/news/2011-05-mini-black-holes-atoms-earth.html http://phys.org/news/2011-05-mini-black-holes-atoms-earth.ht... TL/DR: 1. Tiny black holes as a dark matter candidate; hundreds might pass through the earth every year 2. Difficult but not impossible to detect a black hole of 100 thousand kg passing through the earth 3. A black hole with a mass of 10 million kg at the center of the Earth would take 10^13 years to absorb the planet -- much longer than Earth will survive anyway
- platz 11y ago"according to this theory"
- nitrogen 11y agoOne cannot accept the parts of established theory that say black holes of a certain size might exist without also accepting the remaining parts that say what a black hole of that size can and cannot do. It's like accepting science enough to believe in cosmological constants, but not accepting science's measurements of those constants.
- platz 11y agoI disagree. That's like saying we don't need to do experiments, because everything follows from a few axioms. The reason we refine theories is because they sometimes fail when pushed to their limits. Additionally, parts of a theory may be valid only certain contexts. Newton's laws work wonderfully at human scales, but not at extremes. Similarly, the Standard Model works wonderfully on the familiar things we've tested.. but maybe the Standard Model doesn't work the same way at high energies and it doesn't explain dark matter/energy anyway.. We just don't much about what black holes are like below the Schwarzschild Radius. We haven't even detected Hawking Radiation yet.
- ars 11y ago> One cannot accept the parts of established theory that say black holes of a certain size might exist without also accepting the remaining parts that say what a black hole of that size can and cannot do. That is 100% not true. We don't know what a black hole will do, we just guess. Until we actually measure one we have no idea if there are surprises we have not thought about - or that we simply did not have any way to know were possible since such an environment does not exist on earth. > It's like accepting science enough to believe in cosmological constants, but not accepting science's measurements of those constants. Is there something wrong with doing that? You have no idea if (for example) those constants are actually constant. You have no idea if those constants vary based on some local environment. Perhaps even based on some other constant that we don't even know exists because we have never been able to measure things any other way. There are a TREMENDOUS number of assumptions baked into theories. And we try to test as many of those assumptions as possible all the time, but there could be assumptions we did not even realize we were making. You should really look into the history of science - it will give you some humility. At every age we thought we were at the pinnacle of science, only for later generations to find out things we never realized. There is no reason whatsoever to expect this generation to be any different.
- EvanAnderson 11y agoAm I the only one who finds the photo of the spillway intake off-putting?
- phaemon 11y agoAnother concern with CERN's activities: http://www.askamathematician.com/2012/04/q-will-cern-awaken-the-elder-gods/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2012/04/q-will-cern-awaken-...
- dclowd9901 11y agoSo when a black hole collapses, it explodes? I don't think I really understand a black hole's lifecycle.
- yongjik 11y agoTangentially related: Thorne–Żytkow object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne%E2%80%93%C5%BBytkow_object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne%E2%80%93%C5%BBytkow_obj... A hypothetical red giant that swallowed a neutron star, which sinks into the center and replaces the giant's core. Even at such a scale, the star is relatively stable (i.e., it doesn't go all kaboom immediately) because the matter falling into the neutron core is heated to such a degree that it can balance the inward pressure from gravity.
- bitwize 11y ago> (i.e., it doesn't go all kaboom immediately) Now I'm imagining astronomers going "Where's the kaboom? There was supposed to be a star-shattering kaboom!"
- kr4 11y agoThere are no true black holes [0] as researched done by Scientist Abhas Mitra and his colleagues. >>> Astronomers have certainly discovered thousands of massive compact objects, which are considered as black hole candidates. In a strict sense, no one can detect a black hole as "not even light can escape" from it. They are at the best quasi-black holes. My research (Journal Mathematical Physics, 2009) has shown that true black holes have zero (gravitational mass) which means their positive mass-energy is neutralized by negative gravitational interaction energy . Thus no massive body can be a true black hole. In addition, my parallel research has independently corroborated this fact that true black holes have M=0! And such M=0 black holes can form only asymptotically, implying they never quite form. And only approximate and quasi-black holes can be formed. Some reports say NASA has confirmed your idea that the so-called black holes are balls of fire. But you say that's not exactly ... Yes. The NASA report does not mention my research and admits that `Black Holes are not Black Holes'. But the NASA research certainly bolsters my findings because eruption of corona from a black hole is not understood, as admitted in the NASA report. On the other hand, it gets most naturally explained by the MECO paradigm by which the socalled black holes are balls of ultra-magnetized fire (plasma) -something like the Sun. My research has shown that there cannot be any true black hole. It is just a point and all vacuum with an imaginary boundary Event Horizon from which even light cannot escape. So if the corona (charged particles) have been inferred to be ejected from Black Hole, it means it is not a true Black Hole as claimed in 15 peer reviewed papers by me and collaborators. We also showed that as a star would get hotter and hotter during Black Hole formation, there will be a stage when the radiation pressure of the star material would counter the pull of gravity. This is a quasi-static state and the hot star material would be plasma. What's your take on Stephen Hawking? Hawking has been trying to resolve Black Hole Information Paradox (created by himself in 1976). Failing to do so, from 2004, he has been making noises that "there may not be exact EH" (2004), and "there cannot be any true black hole " (2014) from some vague Quantum Gravity argument which nobody understands, not even those who believe in black holes . In contrast, my proof is exact, comple te and supported by observations, and based on simple general relativity, no unspecified quantum gravity nonsense. Many Nobel laureates too have been struggling to resolve this paradox, but they want to keep black holes alive. Nobody wants to kill the goose, which has been laying golden eggs. In contrast, only my research resolves it meaningfully , by showing there is no black hole, no EH. Hence, there is no paradox in the first place. You see, black hole is one of the biggest physics paradigms for almost 100 years with thousands of celebrity professors, researchers, Nobel Laureates having personal stake. Who would like to set their own Lanka on fire? <<< 0: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/science/There-are-no-true-black-holes-Scientist-Abhas-Mitra/articleshow/49966468.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/science/There-are-no...