3 ms·
> If all of the web rendering engines worked off branches of the same open source code base, I don't think you'd see many people working on the frontend crying,
by pcwalton 11y ago
> If all of the web rendering engines worked off branches of the same open source code base, I don't think you'd see many people working on the frontend crying, and nobody would be locked into a particular platform like we were with IE.
> That said, I'm more interested in Mozilla's work on Servo (and Rust in general) than Firefox/Gecko.
These statements are contradictory. If you get what you want in your first paragraph, Servo won't be possible, ever.
- johncolanduoni 11y agoThe first not what I want, it's the future I think this article is actually predicting (as opposed to IE round two), and I'm saying it won't be such a crying shame. Also not "possible ever" is pretty hyperbolic, considering the lock-in when IE had a monopoly was far stronger than it would be if Chrome/Blink got a monopoly. At the worst we'd have a permissively licensed reference implementation, which is a lot better than trying to be compatible with a closed source blob like IE.
- pcwalton 11y agoClosed versus open source isn't a big deal in terms of difficulty of reverse engineering. It's relatively easy to figure out what IE does; Hixie even clean room reverse engineered IE's entire HTML parsing algorithm back in the day. Having to be bug-for-bug compatible with one engine with no sensible specification is what causes the problems.