3 ms·
>* framers never intended for the federal government to impose uniform standards on state justice systems* Technically correct, but you have to ignore the XIII
by Zigurd 11y ago
>* framers never intended for the federal government to impose uniform standards on state justice systems*
Technically correct, but you have to ignore the XIIIth and XIVth to make that relevant to today.
- rayiner 11y agoWhile that's the Supreme Court's post hoc interpretation, you have to admit it finds little support in either the text or history of those amendments. It's unlikely the states that ratified those amendments realized they were giving up the right to set local standards of how to treat the accused, etc.
- Zigurd 11y agoI would base minimum federal standards of local criminal justice and election conduct and etc. on the commerce clause, if it were up to me. Not meeting such standards amounts to claiming you should be allowed to build highways that won't accept heavy trucks. It would make it hard to do business nationally. But, yeah, Reconstruction and subsequent events shaped those Amendments.