2 ms·
You're right, many of his arguments do indeed apply to lending to new small enterprises in general, and he actually references a UK working paper making a simil
by makomk 11y ago
You're right, many of his arguments do indeed apply to lending to new small enterprises in general, and he actually references a UK working paper making a similar argument about small business funding here. This isn't an argument against lending and entrepreneurship in general; there's strong arguments for lending to existing businesses to ensure they don't run into cashflow issues (if profitable businesses go insolvent it's costly and disruptive), and to allow them to operate more efficiently since this means they can offer the same products for less.
Also, it should be obvious why the immense profitability of microlending institutions is an issue if you think about what that means. It's effectively a transfer of cash from the poorest sectors of society to wealthy investors, and with no countervailing transfer in the opposite direction - because those microbusinesses are selling to other people like them, not wealthy investors - that just makes the poor poorer.