3 ms·
Ask HN: Why 80 characters for titles?
Title editorialism is considered a faux-paux on HN, however, articles optimize their titles to fit in 140 characters due to Twitter and other similar platforms.
However, there are many titles that I feel I have made worse by shortening them to fit on HN (both having made it to the front page, and also not having made it).
Is there any real reason why HN doesn't switch to 140 as well?
Also, I feel shorter headlines leads towards more clickbait-like submissions making it to the front page.
- BtM909 11y agoOn the other hand, it forces you to think about a catchy title instead of copying and pasting it from other sites
- minimaxir 11y agoHN Rules is to use the original title verbatim when possible.
- DrScump 11y agodang has stated recently (and I would expect a corresponding update to the Guidelines page eventually) that terse or otherwise inadequate titles warrant enhancement for clarity (not to clickbait or unnecessarily dupe). Dupe recognition that doesn't rely purely on title is inevitable.
- dang 11y agoI wouldn't go that far. Some terse titles have a charm or mystique that enhances the HN front page. And it's good for readers here to have to work a little, so not everything should explain itself. Probably what I said is that if one is going to expand on an overly terse title, one should use representative language from the article. That's a partial check against editorialism.
- DrScump 11y agoAll HN articles are archived by punching them into IBM cards, which have an 80-character maximum. But seriously, even 140 is arbitrary. One could ask, why have any limit at all? But given the ephemeral nature of individual postings, if you can't summarize within 80 characters, ask yourself if it's appropriate for the audience at all.
- dang 11y agoI never asked pg about this but knowing his taste for brevity, I assume that the obvious explanation is the correct one.