3 ms·
> It is absolutely essential to bring rogue law enforcement officers to justice, particularly in a post-Ferguson world in which violations of constitutional rig
by kbenson 11y ago
> It is absolutely essential to bring rogue law enforcement officers to justice, particularly in a post-Ferguson world in which violations of constitutional rights have come under intense scrutiny.
That's an odd way to word that. It's essential not because there is more scrutiny, but because it's wrong to allow it to continue. Whether it's being looked at more often is a problem for those that are worried about their conduct, not those that are concerned that justice is not being done.
- cperciva 11y agoIt's essential not because there is more scrutiny, but because it's wrong to allow it to continue. It's essential for both reasons. As you correctly point out, it's important to end abuses simply by virtue of the fact that they are abusive and illegal; but it is also important to end practices which bring the justice system into disrepute, since the very functioning of the justice system relies upon the trust which society places upon it. This is a case where both the facts and the public perception thereof are important.
- nickff 11y agoSo maintaining the 'justice system' is an ends in itself? Why should I care whether or not the government has a particular department? Your argument seems to presume that the 'justice system' is good, or that it needs to be kept around for some other reason.
- cperciva 11y agoSo maintaining the 'justice system' is an ends in itself? Not an end in itself, but I'd say it's a very important component in maintaining an ordered society. Whether you consider that to be a worthwhile end may depend on your political leanings; I'm a Canadian, and where the US constitution exhorts the "blessings of liberty", ours speaks of "peace, order, and good government".
- nickff 11y agoMy political leanings are skeptical; it seems to me that the objectives of the police and prosectors are (respectively) to preserve the police and the prosecutors. When crime increases, the police say they are underfunded and overworked, while prosecutors call for additional funding and powers. When crime goes down, they claim it is thanks to their intelligence and dilligence. Both groups are also known for avoiding being held responsible when they fail at their jobs (such as by shooting unarmed people who happen to also be naked, or convicting the innocent through fraudulent evidence).[1][2] Are the police and prosecutors really focused and achieving the maintenance of an ordered society, or are they just keeping their jobs? [1] http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/10/us/georgia-officer-fatal-shooting/ http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/10/us/georgia-officer-fatal-shoot... [2] too many citations to put here
- cperciva 11y agoI never said that I thought we should protect every individual member of the justice system. Quite to the contrary, I think preserving and enhancing the public trust in the justice system requires that individuals who have acted abusively are not protected.
- nickff 11y agoMy point was not that there have been individual failures, but that the 'justice system' is plagued by a lack of accountability, misaligned incentives, and entire organizations who do not feel any obligation to the citizenry.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tbrownaw 11y agoSo maintaining the 'justice system' is an ends in itself? Why should I care whether or not the government has a particular department? There needs to be a systematic and reasoned standard way for people to have redress of grievances, which does not take things to excess. Having this be handled by the government seems to be a reasonably good solution. Having people handle things themselves isn't reasoned or systematic or standardized and does tend to excess, and is bad for everyone. As tends to be demonstrated fairly clearly every time it happens. If the current system of having the government handle this collapses or loses people's trust -- assuming this isn't due to some better system being implemented -- it would only leave people to handle things however they feel, and would be rather harmful.
- Frondo 11y agoYou don't need to care, but if you're going to suggest that a country (or state or city or whatever) doesn't need a justice department, you'd do well to show us a country/state/city without one, and how well they're doing.
- cjhveal 11y agoI agree it's an odd wording. Giving the author the benefit of the doubt, however, I might interpret it to mean that it's essential for continued public trust in law enforcement that rights violations are dealt due process, particularly when they are national spectacles.
- nickff 11y agoPublic trust in law enforcement should be preserved, especially when they are national spectacles? Why? Law enforcement agencies of the government are fascinating, but I do not see why they or any other arm of the government must be preserved; the citizens are what matter, not the government.
- protomyth 11y agoThe logic is that public trust needs to be preserved for cops to do their jobs. If they are national spectacles than they are not going to be able to do the job the citizens who pay for government expect. Its basically an alternate way of saying the police must be clean. Sadly, some politicians forget that in order to respect police we need to see them as non-corrupt. They just expect blind trust.
- cjhveal 11y agoPublic trust is essential for law enforcement to function efficiently. Trust in the legitimacy of government and other members of society is inversely correlated with crime and corruption. This is not to say that trust causes lower crime rates, but when agents of the government behave in ways that break trust and jeopardize the legitimacy of their station, the public is less willing to cooperate and more likely to operate outside of the system of law. Therefore, what is essential is that law enforcement act in ways that preserves trust, especially when the eyes of the nation are upon them. Trust and government behaviour form a feedback loop, such that if either one is maligned, it can disturb the stability of the entire system. I agree citizens are what matter, and that no government agency should be legitimized merely by its own existence. However, I do believe that the enforcement of the law leads to more optimal societal configurations than the Nash equilibrium. I'm not arguing for the preservation of a corrupt and self-serving government agency, I'm arguing that an institution which behaves in a manner that the public can trust will lead to greater utility for society.
- phyzome 11y agoWhen the justice system is visibly flawed, people are more likely to take out their anger and frustration in extralegal ways. This is often considered to be a bad thing.