3 ms·
Instead of proving the thesis, the article merely describes what elitism is. Ironically, this definition proves that programming is probably the least elitist f
by golergka 11y ago
Instead of proving the thesis, the article merely describes what elitism is. Ironically, this definition proves that programming is probably the least elitist field there is.
> Elitists aren’t interested in sharing knowledge, they’re interested in being the source of the knowledge.
Compare how easy it is to learn programming on the web to any other profession. Oh! And you can use only content that was created by professional programmers in their spare time (SO answers, forum posts, RTFMs and FAQs, all the free software), without actually using any content that was created by people who were paid for that (all the code academies) — and still learn pretty much everything.
> these novices have access to tools and shortcuts that the elitist never had
I don't think a lot of programmers actually think like that. I've never seen a programmer who declared that "if you never wrote a compiler, you're not a true programmer". This actually seems like a ridiculous strawman.
But regardless if you like it or not, there are "real" and "not-real" programmers, yes. Unfortunately, "not-real" programmers can actually have titles like "Lead Developer" and even "IT Director", but not be able to solve a FizzBuzz problem in a way that doesn't make hair stand up on your head. And for some reason, the quality of writing good code is correlated with such things as "learning programming for it's own merit", or "getting a CS degree from a good school", or "having a good understanding of mathematical logic and set theory".
(Once again, I have to repeat myself: _correlation_. If you decide that I'm saying that people without CS degrees aren't real programmers, it means that you don't know how to understand what you read).
So, I would never say that "coding academies are nonsense". Any loud, non-compromising statement of this kind is anti-intellectual and most of the time blatantly false. Even the concept of "realness" of a programmer as a binary trait is already oversimplified. But scepticism that IT professionals have about code academy graduates has a very serious root in reality.
It's not about being "threatened". It's about maintaining bad programmer's code.