5 ms·
Tech's Big Gender Diversity Push, One Year In
- parennoob 11y agoFor me, a non-white person from a country where some of the population actually suffers from starvation, this is one of the paragraphs that illustrates my problem with a lot of these diversity efforts. > I ask Mason about this—would she do it? Would she consider a job with a bunch of white dudes? "No," she laughs, because the answer is obvious. "Maybe they’re screwed and it’s a problem they created. But if it were a great work environment, they’d be able to attract a diverse workforce." I can't help but ask (and I hope this is a reasonable question), why are companies pushing so hard to attract these women? I am not white, but I have zero problems working in an environment with 100% white dudes, 100% Asian women, or 100% any other group, so long as I am treated with a decent amount of respect. If a person is attracting funding for her initiatives (e.g. From the article – "Other companies, like Intel, have commendably devoted hundreds of millions of dollars to diversity programs"), but wouldn't even consider working at places just because they have a certain ethnic or gender mix regardless of their actual behavior, it is not at all clear to me that said initiative should be widely promoted or endorsed.
- emgoldstein 11y agoI'd love it if articles like this came with links to scientific evidence that XX-chromosome humans have the same distribution of interests and aptitudes as XY-chromosome humans. Alternatively, maybe HN readers have some such links? At the very least, I'd hope reasonable people could agree that in a universe where this scientific hypothesis isn't true, or turns out not to be true, this situation looks very different from the way the article (which seems to assume it is true) presents it. Certainly, Occam's razor being a thing, any falsification of this hypothesis would be a very parsimonious explanation for the statistical disparities being observed.
- mdorazio 11y agoNo offense, but you seem to be fishing for a genetic justification for sexism in the workplace, and I don't think you're going to find it. The only thing genetics will tell you is if people have physical aptitude for one type of work/activity, which may or may not make them more interested in a certain vocation. The scientific findings are muddy at best, with some studies [1] showing that development factors are the leading cause of interest, and others [2] showing some correlation for twins raised apart. And while yes, there are some small differences in things like spatial reasoning between genders [3], you would be hard pressed to show how this translates into some legitimate reason for women not wanting to write code. It's far, far more likely that social pressures account for most of the disparity in STEM careers. You don't even have to look farther than the kids toys aisle at Walmart - girls are marketed barbies, while boys are marketed RC cars. [1] http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2013/05/14/182633402/how-can-identical-twins-turn-out-so-different http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2013/05/14/18263340... [2] https://books.google.com/books?id=YqanMBTJbxwC&lpg=PA300&ots=seDOwcILro&dq=identical%20twins%20interests&pg=PA300#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=YqanMBTJbxwC&lpg=PA300&ots... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spatial_visualization_ability#Gender_differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spatial_visualization_ability#...
- mycroft-holmes 11y agoYou seem to be fishing for science that supports little difference between genders when there is plenty to say otherwise.
- mdorazio 11y agoCare to provide some actual data to back that up?
- emgoldstein 11y agoNo, I'm asking you to produce evidence for a hypothesis you seem to believe. I don't have any hypothesis of my own. If you tell me that the Sears Tower and the Empire State Building are the same height (a hypothesis), you should show up with evidence that they are the same height, or some other a priori reason to believe that your hypothesis is more likely to be true than untrue (for instance, if both buildings were the product of the same prefab factory). [1] is a rat study. How it relates to any hypothesis about XY versus XX humans is beyond me. If XX and XY humans have different interests/aptitudes, that's a very parsimonious explanation for the toy aisle at Walmart, right? But if your hypothesis is true, we need to search for other explanations. For instance, Walmart and other toy stores might be controlled by a conspiracy of conservative Christians who believe in different gender roles, and are willing to sacrifice profits (from boys buying Barbies, girls buying cars, etc) to support their goal of an unequal society. Is this the hypothesis you're proposing? It also needs to apply to Target, etc, all of which have the same boy/girl aisles.
- mdorazio 11y agoThe fact that you asked for "evidence that XX-chromosome humans have the same distribution of interests and aptitudes as XY-chromosome human" shows that you believe the opposite. Otherwise you wouldn't ask for the evidence in the first place. And I just gave you some evidence, but you seem to think it's not good enough. That's about as good as the research gets, which is itself a commentary on how little the scientific community seems to think this line of questioning is worthwhile. But fine, here's some more: https://books.google.com/books?id=xeYJAAAAQBAJ&lpg=PA110&ots=TXIS4qYk8x&dq=Lawrence%20Cohen%20inborn%20differences&pg=PA110#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=xeYJAAAAQBAJ&lpg=PA110&ots... I'm trying to figure out how you would even begin to do an objective study of what you're looking for since by the time kids present meaningful interests, they're already irrevocably influenced by society and their parents' expectations. And no, that's not a parsimonious explanation at all, it's one of many that fits a particular narrative. Equally plausible is that toys today are a relic of thousands of years of traditional gender role pressures that have no place in today's knowledge economy. You can trace "dolls are for girls" back to hunter-gatherer times where it made sense for boys to be given knives and bows, and girls to be given baskets and dolls. The problem is those roles are deeply ingrained in today's society even though they don't make much sense anymore since today women are more likely to build robots than men are to hunt their own food. [1] Is a genetics study, the very thing you're asking for evidence of. That's how you would test a hypothesis that genetics is key to occupational interest -- look at two animals with identical genetics and see if they show the same interests regardless of environmental factors. If they don't, then the entire XX vs. XY distinction is a moot point. i.e. if two people with literally the same DNA don't show the same interests (as is the case for many identical twins), that's rather strong evidence that genetics doesn't mean much for occupational choice at all. And if you're discounting the study merely because it uses rats, you're going to have to throw out an awful lot of research from the last 100 years on just about everything related to biology.
- mdorazio 11y agoHonest question: is it morally fair to be creating big incentives for hiring female workers in tech positions that aren't offered to men? I am 100% in agreement that there is a huge problem, but am personally of the opinion that we need to fix early-life biases to actually create more female engineers and executives rather than trying to entice the few STEM-educated female graduates into jobs they may or may not want. It just seems to me like tech companies are creating an equivalent of college affirmative action, which could backfire by creating animosity from male job applicants who get passed over because they're not in the right gender bucket to meet quotas.
- iokevins 11y agoSounds like you prefer more equality and meritocracy, in hiring--is that right? I'm glad to see we are in agreement about the existence and significance of the problem. Opinions naturally will differ, on strategies to pursue--one note the article mentioned was a perceived ding on the current investment of resources in pursuing strategies. More resources, more strategies, including early life and others?
- mdorazio 11y agoKevin, I prefer equal opportunity in as many parts of life as possible, including hiring. Do you have any stats on strategies being actively pursued by companies beyond "we need to hire more women"? The article made mention of some, but didn't go into specifics on how seriously they were being taken. I would personally like to see the bigger tech companies move toward training + hiring programs for women who aren't already STEM educated (we obviously need more engineers across the board, and the reliance on traditional CS/EE degrees really frustrates me) and toward creating tools and training materials for parents to use with their daughters in early life. A lot of the effort in the latter area seems to be coming from parents themselves, sometimes with help from Kickstarter (ex. Robot Turtles).
- iokevins 11y agoThe article uses the Anita Borg Institute’s "Grace Hopper Celebration of Women In Computing" as a window, to assess industry challenges: gender numbers not moving, transparency, awareness, hiring practices, leaky pipelines, perceptions, and bias. It concludes with strategies a number of companies have taken.