7 ms·
How the Atari ST Almost Had Real Unix (2011)
- mrpippy 11y agoThe author comments here at HN pretty often: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=kabdib https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=kabdib
- pmoriarty 11y agoI'll just add that I found the author's story of how he started working at Atari in the first place[1] far more interesting than the present article. [1] - http://www.dadhacker.com/blog/?p=987 http://www.dadhacker.com/blog/?p=987
- scholia 11y agoMany thanks for that link: it's a great story.
- robin_reala 11y agoSite’s down; cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http%3A%2F%2Fwww.dadhacker.com%2Fblog%2F%3Fp%3D1383 https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http%3...
- kabdib 11y agoSorry, it's on GoDaddy. Every once in a while my blog gets popular and . . . well, I guess I should move it off of GoDaddy.
- j45 11y agoGreat story. This machine was remarkably capable for it's time and age for both business and personal use. I was lucky enough to spend a few years with this machine as my primary, only can imagine if I was exposed to unix on top of the graphic, digital creation and other tools.
- gaius 11y agoWhen you consider what the Atari ST, Commodore Amiga and Acorn Archimedes were capable of in the late 80s and early 90s, you see how little progress we've really made.
- agumonkey 11y agoThe arrow of mainstream time is backward most of the time.
- rbanffy 11y agoThere isn't much point in going beyond "sufficient", so, I would not expect much progress beyond what a common user would need to be made. Beyond that point, if we want to make better computers, we need to make compelling software that needs them to run. This is how GUIs, multitasking, multicore, memory protection, GPUs and 64-bits became mainstream. I am not oblivious to the fact my Windows machine of 1991 was science-fiction when I got my first Apple II as would the prospect of having 6 ARM-based UNIX machines (one of them off because the battery is drained) on my desk or the fact I am running 3 Linux VMs and one LXC container while I work, would be unthinkable in 1991. What annoys me is that the machines you mention were remarkably simple and elegant machines (Amiga was elegant, but very simple) while a modern PC is a matryoshka of nested computers all the way down to an 8088-powered IBM PC 5150. There must even be a cassette port (connected to nothing, of course) somewhere in a modern PC chipset.
- marincounty 11y agoI had an Atari St something(1200?) in college. I never told any of my professors, or classmates about my computer. I literally felt like I was cheating. I was afraid someone would detect the matrix print, but no one ever questioned my papers. I did have professors bleed red all over my papers though. My grammer was just horrid. My spelling was great though. In one English class, a student plugged in a laptop(it was the size of a small suitcase) into a electrical socket. The teacher made some demeaning comment to the student. It was someting like, 'I never thought I would see the day where a student plugged in a computer? Ugh?' I remember thinking that student has some balls, but has a great tool at his disposal. Never liked that English teacher. He accused me of plagiarizing once--in a weird round about way. Ah, back then teachers had a lot of power. They could ruin a student's future. I remember trying to get my girlfriend interested in my Atari. She was paying 2 dollars a page for someone to type her papers. I showed her the word program. I showed her the Paint program. She didn't like anything about the machine. She didn't even want be near the machine. She is now some big wig at some hedge fund. Her official title is chief of web technology, or something along those lines. I haven't gone one day where I haven't thought about her. Crazy? I look back, and I couldn't get anyone interested in my computer. It was like people just hated them? Couldn't figure out why. I wasen't a big tech guy either, and only used the word processing program. I remember thinking, I guess the computer thing will never take off. I was so wrong. I remember my last visit to the retail store that sold me the Atari, and I could tell they were about to close up shop. My last memory is of a big guy with a beard, and he looked so depressed. All the computers were nicely displayed, but no customers. They even turned off the shopping music. There was this weird silence, and a feeling of doom. I think the shop stayed open a few more weeks, and it turned into some shop that made custom doors? Looking back, I just have fond memories of my college girlfriend. I wish I treated her better. I think I have holiday blues?
- luckydude 11y agoIt is possible to make VM work with the 68000, Masscomp did it but it was pretty brute force, they ran two 68000's in lock step with one just behind the other so when the first one faulted it stopped the other one and the other handled the fault. Something like that. Clem Cole would know the exact details. They made for a pretty beefy machine, I ran ~20 users on one. That was when we had a pile students on a Vax 11/780, I had accounts on both and much preferred the Masscomp.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoI think there were several manufacturers who used that trick. Apollo was another. That wasn't really an option for consumer-grade machines like the Atari ST, though, since 68000 chips were pretty expensive at the time (I think they were around $500 apiece when they were introduced). By the time the price came down the later 680x0 chips with real MMUs were available.
- aswanson 11y agoWow. $500 for a 68000?!
- kabdib 11y agoI don't recall the COGs for the ST (they held this stuff pretty close), but in 1985, the 68000 CPU couldn't have been more than $50, probably less. Almost certainly much less because the Tramiels were absolute wizards at making deals.
- bryanlarsen 11y ago1985 was 6 years after the 68K was reduced. By Moore's law, the cost of manufacturing should have been about 1/16th of what it was in 1979, so the volume price was probably around 1/16th of introduction as well.
- kabdib 11y ago
- jacquesm 11y agoSo essentially he re-invented segmented memory for memory protection purposes. Neat hack! There was a brown box at the time, iirc by Torch (?) that ran a version of Unix on a 68K. Does anybody know which machine that was? The 6809 OS that was 'unix like' referenced in the comments is about OS/9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OS-9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OS-9 Which is a really neat little OS that you can run on the TRS-80 CoCo and the UK clone of it called the 'Dragon 32'.
- arethuza 11y agoIf it was a "brown box" maybe it was a Cromemco? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cromemco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cromemco
- jacquesm 11y agoNo it most resembled a cube each side about 30 cm or so. It's ages ago and my memory about this is hazy, I saw the machine exactly once. Now I really want to find out. Edit: Ah, got it: http://chrisacorns.computinghistory.org.uk/docs/Torch/Torch_Unicorn.pdf http://chrisacorns.computinghistory.org.uk/docs/Torch/Torch_... Indeed, the Torch Unicorn, Unix on a 68000. Makes you wonder what they did for MMU, apparently it ran Unix System 3
- arethuza 11y agoI remember reading about them in what was probably "PC World" - first time I'd read about Unix or seen C code. I was amazed that you could program without line numbers... :-)
- kabdib 11y agoI knew about segmented memory. But base/bounds was too expensive and slow. The trick was to make it work without requiring an adder -- and subsequent carry propagation delay -- in the data path. Thus, "one gate delay" and simple replacement of address lines, and a simple "all zeros or all ones" check on the bounds, rather than a numeric comparison.
- afreak 11y agoIt should be noted that certain 680x0 Macintoshes could run a real UNIX, created by Apple no less. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX What was unique about it was that it could run System 7 applications alongside your common System V/BSD tools. I've still got a Quadra 800 at home running it.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoThat was a real missed opportunity, the equivalent of OS X decades earlier
- rbanffy 11y agoIt did require a ridiculously expensive computer for its time, well into the workstation range, but with a relatively puny hardware compared to what Sun could offer at the time.
- nrr 11y agoMore aptly, FPU and MMU hardware were incredibly expensive in the late 1980's and early 1990's, and the amount of RAM to sustain running A/UX would've crept you closer into workstation territory anyway. Keep in mind that this was a time when one was not guaranteed to have memory segmentation hardware, let alone floating point hardware. We take this for granted in 2015, but in the period between 1985 and 1995, it was a serious luxury for lots of computer buyers. That said, with 4MB of 60ns RAM and a 68030 costing you $10k to start on a Mac IIfx and an upgrade to take you up to 8MB potentially costing you another couple grand, why not just go SGI and be done with it?
- yuhong 11y ago1MB SIMMs was much cheaper than this by then, though the IIfx was famous for requiring special 64 pin SIMMs.
- ams6110 11y agoEquivalent? No. Unix is not the secret sauce of OSX. I never used A/UX. Did it have a GUI at all?
- peter303 11y agoPCs were too weak to run UNIX in the 1980s. MicroSoft was the vender for Xenix, a 16-bit UNIX. It was so slow compared to PDP 11 UNIX. 32 bit x86 CPUs and Linux came out about the same time in the early 90s- a successful marriage.
- ams6110 11y agoI ran Minix on a 8088 with 640K RAM and a 5.25" floppy drive.
- tzs 11y agoAh...Microsoft and Xenix. Those were responsible for the most annoying meeting I have ever been forced to attend. When AT&T and Sun were doing their joint Unix stuff with SysVR4, they had a deal with Microsoft to add 286 Xenix compatibility. Microsoft contracted with Interactive Systems Corporation (ISC) in Santa Monica, CA, to do the work (which made sense, because as part of ISC's contract to do the 386 port of SysVR3 for AT&T, ISC had done a 286 Unix binary compatibility system). I worked at ISC at the time, and the 286 Xenix compatibility was done by Darryl Richman and myself. At one point Microsoft told us that there was a serious issue that had to be decided, and it was too important to handle over the phone or email. They wanted both Darryl and I to fly to Redmond. This annoyed me, because I strongly avoid flying [1]. (During the flight, though, I did see something interesting. Over Northern California I saw a black aircraft very rapidly ascending. As far as I could tell, we were at around the right latitude for Beale AFB, which was a major starting point for SR-71 and U-2 spy missions, so one of those could have been what I saw). So we finally get to the meeting, and they bring up the massive issue that could only be dealt with in person. There were one or two differences in signal behavior between Xenix and SysVR4 that could not be taken care of in our user mode code. They would need to add an option to the kernel to switch to Xenix behavior for programs running under our Xenix emulator. That was no problem--they knew how to do that. What they did not know, and needed this urgent face to face meeting to discuss, was whether the interface to that option should be an ioctl or a new system call. WTF!? We told them to go with an ioctl (if I recall correctly), they said that would be fine, and the meeting was over. If that wasn't annoying enough, when the project was done Microsoft said they were very happy with the results and they expressed this by sending Darryl a bunch of free Microsoft software. They sent me nothing. Now if Darryl had been the project lead or principle engineer or something like that on the project, that would have been fine. But we were equal...and I actually was the more experienced in that area because the 286 Xenix emulation was based on the 286 Unix emulation which had been done by Carl Hensler and me. [1] I believe everyone is allowed, and should have, one stubbornly irrational fear, and I picked for mine flying on aircraft that I am not piloting.
- pmelendez 11y ago> "[What’s that about Linux? Dear child, Linus was probably not out of whatever they use for high school in Finland." I think not even that... I think Atari ST came out in 1985 and if I remember right, Linus started working on Linux in 1991, so not even in the picture at that time.
- rasz_pl 11y agoLinus had Sinclair QL at the time, also Motorola 6800x, sadly x was in wrong place making whole computer a pile of garbage
- scholia 11y agoThis came about after Sun and AT&T decided to standardise the Unix industry on SVR4. Having lots of cheap Atari, Amiga and other micros running SVR4 would have helped it dominate the industry. In theory, at least. This prompted DEC (Ultrix), HP (HP-UX), IBM (AIX) and other companies to band together to develop their own standard Unix, which was OSF/1 (Open Software Foundation, or as Scott McNealy said, "Oppose Sun Forever"). This kicked off another round of Unix Wars, which was no doubt much appreciated in Redmond, where Windows NT was being developed. The Atari SVR4 was ported by Unisoft and there's a video of it booting on a TT 030 workstation (which had a 68030). https://vimeo.com/100657320 https://vimeo.com/100657320 I was at the Atari Unix SVR4 (pre-)announcement at CeBIT in Germany, but it's so long ago I've forgotten the details.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "Having lots of cheap Atari, Amiga and other micros running SVR4 would have helped it dominate the industry." For those that are interested, SVR4 was released for the Amiga. It's a shame Commodore's management blocked it from reaching its full potential. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amiga_3000UX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amiga_3000UX