4 ms·
Why options at all? At startup valuations is the cost that great? According to the Buffett worldview (I think) Actual shares align shareholders interests, unli
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
Why options at all? At startup valuations is the cost that great?
According to the Buffett worldview (I think) Actual shares align shareholders interests, unlike option grants, in later stage companies.
To my mind options are a free and usually worthless offer. But actual shares have a value and significance, not for their monetary worth, but the actual ownership.
I must admit I am hazy on the details of options - but then as I am a profile of typical early employee perhaps that's also the point
- lmeyerov 11y agoEarly stage shares are illiquid paper money that you have to pay taxes on (or the cash-poor startup does). The higher the valuation, the more you / the startup forks over up front. Options skip that: you only pay if and when things go well, in which case you don't mind. If things fail, you only pay in lost time. They're way more employee friendly.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoBut that seems a failure of the tax system (tax on a asset worth less than the tax is silly). And illiquid should not be the issue surely. We don't want the employees selling the shares - but we do want them as part owners. These days Inwoukd assume my right to an option could be tradeable, even securitisable.
- knughit 11y agoStartups can't fix the tax system.
- lmeyerov 11y agoOptions are the right to buy shares at a frozen (& cheap) price. Incentives are aligned because, if the employee helps make the company more valuable, the share value goes up, and they get to walk away with the difference. (A slight oddity is that technically their value needs to go up to be worth exercising, but because of how they get valued -- ~20% of price early VCs pay ~ as soon as VCs would make money, so would anybody owning options.) Independent of my desires for reform around taxes and illiquidity, offers should be made in terms of the current system, not a make believe one. You may want to read up on this stuff, esp. if you want to work in startups..
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoSo the existence of, if not the acceptance of, forums like equidateinc.com that do run secondary markets in stock options, to me seem a good thing. They mark options as more liquid. One thing that strikes me about all this is that if capital is and remains much easier to access, then the risk of entrepreneurship is diminished, and the reward to founders seems likely to drop too - presumably being shared more with early employees?
- slapshot 11y agoTaxes. At least in the US, if a company with a non-zero valuation grants actual stock to an employee, income tax is due at the time of grant on the difference between what the employee paid and what the stock is "worth" (I'm assuming the employee files an "83(b) election" -- if not then it's even worse). There are only two ways out: either charge the employee the current "fair market value" of the stock (which can be very expensive on day 1) or the employee has to pay taxes on grant (which can also be very expensive on day 1). By contrast, if you grant ISO options, $0 is due in taxes at grant. $0 is due when it vests. Taxes only become relevant when an employee decides whether or not to exercise. As Altman discusses, there's an argument to be made that it should be 10 years after quitting rather than 90 days after quitting, but either way it gives the employee a lot more information about whether this is a good company or not.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoSo the big issue is determining worth of the stock. Which suggests that while the investment points are interesting, a genuine market in startup shares would be a better way to value them. What are the legal hurdles to either direct trading in shares in next-Facebook or in trading instruments that represent the options an employee receives? I am a fan of open markets and exchanges so this seems a good idea at solving price discovery (is squares recent IPO should not have been such a surprise if there was a market pricing its employees options)