4 ms·
The problem is not technological, it's definitional. From the definition of "society", any society must make decisions that affect all of its members, otherwis
by nostrademons 11y ago
The problem is not technological, it's definitional.
From the definition of "society", any society must make decisions that affect all of its members, otherwise they aren't a society, they're a collection of non-interacting individuals. From the definition of "decision", these decisions must be framed by an individual - we have yet to master mind-meld technologies. From the definition of "power", the people who make the decisions have the power.
Majority voting is a red-herring. The way that existing power structures operate today is to frame the terms of the decision: they define what the alternatives are. Take a look at who sponsors ballot initiatives in California: very often, you'll find that a process that's as close to direct democracy as you'll get in modern society was actually sponsored by a wealthy billionaire or corporation behind the scenes, and he has crafted both the legislation and the public messaging around the legislation to suit his interests. If the voting public is faced with two alternatives and option A enriches elite #1 at the expense of the public while option B enriches elite #2 at the expense of the public, you can't really say that the voters have power.
- touchofevil 11y agoI do agree that the US should break away from the two party system, as either choice seems to yield only bad or worse results for the citizens.
- lsc 11y ago> I do agree that the US should break away from the two party system, as either choice seems to yield only bad or worse results for the citizens. Worse than what? I mean, sure, nobody is 100% happy with the outcome, but some people say that's how you tell that a negotiation had a fair outcome.
- Asbostos 11y agoBut that's what most people want. If they didn't want it, they wouldn't keep voting for the same two parties or not bothering to vote. Why not just accept that the majority likes it that way, even if you feel it gives bad results? I guess I'm making the assumption that democracy has the goal of giving people what they want. Whereas perhaps a more noble goal would be giving people what will benefit them. People are notoriously irrational at deciding what will benefit them though, so who could possibly make those decisions?
- fulafel 11y agohttp://www.gallup.com/poll/185891/majority-maintain-need-third-major-party.aspx?version=print http://www.gallup.com/poll/185891/majority-maintain-need-thi... > A majority of Americans, 60%, say a third major political party is needed because the Republican and Democratic parties "do such a poor job" of representing the American people. (September 25, 2015) In a FPTP system you cannot really deduce what people wanted from the voting results, as the system very strongly encourages tactical voting. (and in this instance also because of Duverger's law)