3 ms·
I think classifications are useful. If I see that a film is rated PG or R or whatever, I have a basic idea of what to expect from it. This is useful. What's no
by mikeash 11y ago
I think classifications are useful. If I see that a film is rated PG or R or whatever, I have a basic idea of what to expect from it. This is useful.
What's not good is when the ratings are enforced by the government. Let people decide for themselves (or for their children). But giving them additional information to decide with is fine.
- SixSigma 11y agoLikewise. When I had a child it was a useful guide to suitability. We used the rating system to warn him of the things that disturbed him. He knew he had bad dreams based on some of the films he watched so we discussed with him that films with an 18 rating could provide him with an experience he wasn't fully prepared to process and this is what causes such disturbance. That we, as adults, didn't concoct the whole certification scheme just to annoy children. Once he got used to the idea and was able to articulate how he felt when presented with 18 rated material by friends, he agreed that the system was a useful framework for himself. Now, I would also argue that the certification process is not perfect and does have nannying built in. Some films have failed to get certification for general release. I am against banning forms of culture and expression. There is plenty of material I find distasteful and unpleasant such as animal torture. I am subscribed to /rr/watchpeopledie on reddit and find it educational. Narco blunt blade beheadings and ISIS executions on video certainly provide a reality check that is missing from news reports. That my govt. chases beheading videos off Facebook is ridiculous. I don't want a nanny state like that.
- CM30 11y agoYeah, this seems pretty reasonable. If someone wants their kid to 'play violent games' or 'watch adult movies', then let them, that's called letting parents decide how to raise their kids. Heck, the whole 'mandatory' ratings thing isn't even that useful in general, since the parent just ends up going in on their own and bringing the game/movie/whatever back to their kid regardless of any 'restrictions'. Heck, it's even more pointless with the internet and no way to verify who anyone actually is.
- slavik81 11y agoIt's bad when it's enforced privately too. 'AO' is the rating for games equivalent to 'NC-17' for movies. You'd think they're be treated similarly, but no console manufacturer will license AO games for their platform, nor will most stores carry them. This has created a de facto ban. There are literally only 27 games that have ever been rated AO [1], because the only real choice a developer has is to censor the game enough to release at a lower rating. Sure, movies do censor themselves for financial reasons too, but they may later release an uncut edition. For games, even that is simply impossible. [1] http://www.esrb.org/ratings/search.aspx http://www.esrb.org/ratings/search.aspx
- mikeash 11y agoI'd say that's an argument for open platforms, not against ratings. I'd bet there are about seventeen million PC games that would be rated AO if they bothered to get rated at all.
- slavik81 11y agoI have no problem with ratings themselves, only with ratings enforcement. Open platforms would solve part of the problem, and I love the PC, but unfortunately closed platforms simply are a huge part of the industry today and for the foreseeable future.