4 ms·
> It’s curious we’ve allowed capitalism to become all about shareholders. For god's sake I hope this view becomes more prevalent. Viewing economy only through
by mschuster91 11y ago
> It’s curious we’ve allowed capitalism to become all about shareholders.
For god's sake I hope this view becomes more prevalent.
Viewing economy only through shareholder's eyes leads to a focus on only short-term gains - which might destroy the company in the future but who cares when stock goes up 10% in a quarter?
Fuck this shit. The economy would fare a LOT better in my eyes if any investor over a certain threshold (10k?) was forced to hold the stock in question for 12 months at a minimum, similar to the waiting periods startup founders/co-owners have to endure before they're allowed to sell their stock.
Such a move would instantly kill off those greedy funds which make a company go deep into debt, pay the money from these debts to the shareholders (i.e. the fund(s)) and then go bankrupt.
edit: also, such a move would prevent people from investing in crapps like Yo, which got at least $2.5M in funding...
- blfr 11y agoThe reason people view the economy through the shareholders' eyes is because very many of them are shareholders and count on the stock market to pay for their retirement. It's also the opposite of looking only for short-term gains.
- mschuster91 11y agoWho, these days, is directly investing in stocks for their retirement? That's absolutely crazy imho. Just choose an index fund if you're in long term (http://www.forbes.com/sites/mitchelltuchman/2013/07/18/hedge-fund-vs-index-fund-a-comparison/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/mitchelltuchman/2013/07/18/hedge...). Fuck hedge funds.
- joshu 11y agoYou mean mutual funds. Hedge funds aren't open to the general public.
- walshemj 11y agoThe why do many of the big stock picking equity income Investment trusts beat the FTSE 100 and over several decades.
- coderjames 11y agoI do, as part of a diversified portfolio. I couldn't find an ETF with reasonable fees that provides the make-up I wanted: long-term history of dividend growth ex-cigarettes/pharma. This dividend stream will provide a meaningful percentage of the income in retirement. It is presently being reinvested for compound growth.
- SeanDav 11y agoWith some notable exceptions, in general, shareholders are not patient people. Their horizon is usually the next quarter's results. After all why keep your shares in a company that is not making a "good enough" return, when you can easily them to the next company that is due to make outstanding returns. I worked in the investment banking industry for many years, on both the buy and sell side and believe me - "long term" is not in most shareholder's vocabulary.
- WalterBright 11y agoOf course shareholders seek to maximize returns. There's nothing wrong with that. BTW, shareholders who churn their accounts tend to do poorly. That doesn't hurt other shareholders, though. But it does mean you don't need to heap further punishment on them.
- lmm 11y agoIf you work in the industry where you're talking to people who buy or sell, of course most of the people you meet will be the ones who buy or sell frequently. You'd never even know the buy-and-hold investors existed, because they're not the ones talking to an investment bank.
- SeanDav 11y agoAgreed, that is a factor, but give me some credit for knowing that. I stand by my original comment.
- Retra 11y agoI'm not sure how most shareholders think, but if it were me, I would certainly not be counting on stock for retirement. I would be looking to increase stock earnings in order to purchase capitol and create business and research opportunities, all of which are things that you don't want to wait for retirement to do.
- twoodfin 11y agoWhy would anyone pay a 10% premium for a company likely to be destroyed?
- rodgerd 11y agoAs long as you realize your gains before the stock tanks, why do you give a fuck? The only people affected are the employees, the customers, and the mugs who invest for the long term. If you expect to make your gains on the stock price (not, say, dividends), it's a perfectly rational strategy. Of course, it leads to things like IBM borrowing money for stock buy-backs to pump the price to make the numbers, which will be a long term disaster...
- bobcostas55 11y agoAnd where do you imagine those gains come from?
- lmm 11y agoIf you can buy something and then convince other people it's worth more than it is then you'll turn a profit while screwing those people, sure. But that's true of anything - cars, houses, bridges....
- HiLo 11y agoNo it's not, your argument excludes factors that are huge in reality. For example, these executives that find themselves in a position to do that usually have only found themselves in that role after an extensive amount of time (10+ years) working for not only that industry, but that company, building their entire reputations. Many of these guys also continue to rely on their network for further opportunities and support. Their network would cut them out like gangrene, just like the old Enron titans, as to maintain their own good standing they couldn't be affiliated with somebody who clearly blew up their past company. That would be bad business, and that type of behavior would have prevented them from reaching those positions in the first place.
- aianus 11y ago
- hirsin 11y agoI'm not sure if my view on this is complacency, fatalism, or somewhat valid, but I disagree. (I agree that it's broken, I don't think there's a good fix) A) we already have such an incentive in the form of long/short term ownership and tax benefits. It hasn't helped (in the sense that this behavior still exists) B) There's always a loophole. You're required to stay in 1 year? Your shares get converted to those of the company that survives. Or they structure the deal such that a holding company is created on day 1, the profits pass through, and the debt issues don't come through until day (requirement +1). Every control on financial deals comes a day late and dollar short - we can't penalize the crooked deals after the fact, and we can't predict what the financial industry will concoct until they do. Further, every law passed will be worked around anyhow because you can always structure a deal to create a loophole. The laws only force ever more creative products (read: complex and fragile). The only simple solution I see is to only allow a subset of deals, with contracts, terms, and arbitration set by the government. And that will never happen (nor be effective really, for the above).
- joshu 11y agoHow would it have prevented someone from investing in Yo, exactly? Fwiw once you own a certain percentage of a public company, there are all sorts of rules about when and how long you can hold stuff.
- WalterBright 11y agoIf it was true that the market wanted to destroy companies for short term gains, you'd make a fortune by shorting the stocks. The reality is, stock prices are a reflection of anticipated future value. If shareholders get wind that the company is destroying its future value, they'll dump the stock as fast as possible. Plenty of companies have high P/Es, meaning that shareholders are clearly in it for the long term.
- oldmanjay 11y agoThank you for the simple, coherent rebuttal to what has become my least favorite anti-corporate illogic. The "all companies are in it for the short term" argument makes as much sense as "weed will never be legal because they can't tax it."
- WalterBright 11y agoA CEO once told me that he (legally) manipulated the books to show the numbers that "Wall Street" wanted. The market wasn't fooled and his stock tanked. Bill Gates once said that he paid no attention to Wall Street or the MSFT stock price - he concentrated on making money and let the stock take care of itself. We all know how that worked out :-)
- HiLo 11y agoI feel like this is reflective of reality and also an under appreciated view. The whole job of a good analyst is to be able to see through and reverse engineer any financial engineering.
- mschuster91 11y agoNot all companies are, yes. But a shockingly high number definitely is! Look outside the class of Apple, Failbook and MS.
- WalterBright 11y agoI'll bite :-) Name two that have the current stock price artificially inflated by destroying the long term company value.
- drjesusphd 11y agoThis attitude is court-enforced. Shareholders have sued in the past and the Supreme Court has ruled that that publicly traded companies exist to serve the interest of shareholders.
- jdc 11y agoCan you give an example of such a case?
- intopieces 11y agoDodge v. Ford Motor Company, 170 NW 668 (Mich 1919); AP Smith Manufacturing Co v Barlow, 98 A.2d 581 (N.J. 1953); Shlensky v Wrigley, 237 NE 2d 776 (Ill. App. 1968)
- tudorw 11y agoYes, this legal situation brings about lots of unwelcome outcomes, environmental and social impacts often have to be put aside by a 'caring' company as the law dictates they must do whatever is legal and best serves the interest of the shareholders. The UK has a relatively new entity that can avoid this and still operate with most of the benefits of a regular limited company, a 'Community Interest Company', the 'community purpose' is regulated. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-the-regulator-of-community-interest-companies https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-the-re... A slightly off-topic aside, but tangentially related... I find promise in the 'Economics of Happiness' and GNH work, it's an emerging term and field attempting to measure human happiness in a consistent manner, this would allow any proposed action to have a line item on the costings with a figure that is derived from the amount of 'happiness' that would be created, or destroyed, as a result. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_National_Happiness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_National_Happiness
- lostcolony 11y agoThe US has B Corporations - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation Probably the most famous company running as a B corp at present would be http://www.bcorporation.net/community/ben-and-jerrys http://www.bcorporation.net/community/ben-and-jerrys
- mnot 11y agoHis words reminded me of the writing of Sumantra Ghoshal: https://www.mnot.net/blog/2005/07/23/ghoshal https://www.mnot.net/blog/2005/07/23/ghoshal
- bwilliams18 11y agoAny investor over 10% has to give up any profits if they buy then sell within six months...
- blt 11y agoIt's unfortunate that going public is viewed as the endgame goal by so many. The best work environments I've been in were private companies. One went from great to awful in a matter of weeks after being acquired by a public company.
- akira2501 11y ago> The economy would fare a LOT better in my eyes if any investor over a certain threshold (10k?) was forced to hold the stock in question for 12 months at a minimum, [...] You can do this naturally by simply increasing the short-term capital gains tax rate; currently it's calculated as pure income tax which maxes out around 40%.