4 ms·
I'm wondering if a reliable caller ID that gives a rough geographical source of the call would prevent most swatting. A supposedly local emergency call that act
by skybrian 11y ago
I'm wondering if a reliable caller ID that gives a rough geographical source of the call would prevent most swatting. A supposedly local emergency call that actually comes from a different country should be considered suspicious. Seems like there are some loopholes to be closed?
- CaptSpify 11y agoThe problem, I think, is that there does need to be a way to "anonymously" report suspicious activity. Imagine a legit call, where the "callee" is known by the "suspicious person". I agree that there's room for improvement/checking, but not sure how to reconcile the two.
- skybrian 11y agoNot sure what you mean since the emergency responders can keep the source of the call confidential. In any case, exact location isn't necessary. It doesn't make sense to treat a local call and a call from somewhere in Canada the same. Most swatting attempts are from far away, so having some indication of location would make it harder to do damage. Also, most calls to 911 are not anonymous - they automatically get caller id even for blocked numbers. It's just that there are some loopholes.
- btown 11y agoAs other commenters have noted, it is possible to buy local area code numbers for use on Google Voice. Very difficult to distinguish a swatter from a true resident of the area.
- hooloovoo_zoo 11y agoIs there really no information in the signal that would tell you what protocols were used to encode / transmit the call?
- someguydave 11y agoNo, there isn't. The metadata is washed away when the VOIP call hits the Signaling System Seven switch. A simple policy fix would solve this problem: Treat any caller willing to threaten police with death but unwilling to reveal his identity with great suspicion.
- hooloovoo_zoo 11y agoThey just need to treat the call differently. Don't go in guns blazing if your call came from a TOR exit node.
- mikeash 11y agoI imagine that would help, but how do you actually implement such a thing?
- VonGuard 11y agoCaller ID is terrible. It was never meant to be a form of security, only to be a service the phone companies could sell access to. It's so incredibly easy to fake Caller ID that it's essentially useless at a macro level. To fix it would require a completely different system, something like the ANI systems phone companies offer. But they hate offering ANIs to the public, sooooo.... Anyone interested in spoofing Caller ID can do so with an Asterisk box. You can put in whatever number you want for the Caller ID.