10 ms·
> and from a police point of view, it’s better to ‘‘respond high and then downgrade’’ They're saying increased risk of killing innocent people = ok, which is a
by DanBC 11y ago
> and from a police point of view, it’s better to ‘‘respond high and then downgrade’’
They're saying increased risk of killing innocent people = ok, which is a sub-optimal approach when you look at the thousand or so people shot and killed by US police each year.
- golergka 11y agoTo be fair, there are innocent lives on both sides of the equation. This article only describes one side of it. A week later someone will post a story about how 911 never responds to calls in Detroit, and the comments will have the opposite message. It's easy to say what should and should not be done in each individual case. It's hard to build a bureaucratic system that intelligently evaluates each case with all information available and consistently makes high-quality decisions.
- detaro 11y agoIt would be really interesting to see the data supporting this: how often has a high response turned out to be the likely correct approach, how often has to "low" response gotten people killed? Sadly I don't think this kind of stuff is tracked on a larger scale.
- onewaystreet 11y agoThe argument for the "show of force" tactic is that a show of force can prevent the use of force because the suspect is too stunned to act.
- DanBC 11y agoWhere "stunned" means "shot and killed within 6 seconds of the officer arriving"? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-34918231 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-34918231
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dibujante 11y agoWell, flip the response around - respond low and then upgrade. It's possible that this would lead to less death overall. But it would also mean that any situation requiring escalation would probably indicate such through the death of a police officer. Would you want to be the sacrificial officer who knocks on the door to find out if the situation is worth escalating? The overall numbers might work out better in that case, but the whole "someone will definitely die" factor is a big psychological hurdle.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't want to be a police officer at all, but for those who are, "put your life on the line for others" is pretty much the job description. By all means, we should minimize their risk as much as is reasonable. But when you get to the end of what's reasonable, you have to accept that they're still going to be at risk, because that's what the job is.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe US has unusually aggressive police, with tactics and doctrine that result in far too much shooting and killing compared to other advanced nations. Yet those other places don't get lots of dead police. Maybe there is a way to do this without "responding high?"
- dibujante 11y agoYou're missing my point; I'm not arguing in favor of responding high, but instead pointing out that responding high is more psychologically comfortable than its numerical consequences would otherwise indicate.
- fenomas 11y agoThe whole thing smells like a system that can't deal with bogus inputs. It's understandable that police want to prepare for the worst, but surely it's a "trust but verify" kind of situation. A swat team that charges in, guns drawn, even without any sign of a threat seems like a fire department that turns on the hoses before they've seen smoke or flame. Then of course, after the police work out a response plan that can cope with bad inputs, step 2 is they need to tell everyone about it. The expectation that cops will point ten guns at anyone you ask them to is the reason swatting is a thing at all.