7 ms·
Palestinian territories to get 3G in mid-2016
- forinti 11y agoI guess this makes it clear (if it wasn't clear enough) that Israel is the state.
- AtlasLion 11y agothe occupying state.
- yohann305 11y agoHN is not a place for political views, there are plenty of other platforms for this, let's not litter HN, let's keep it clean and valuable. Read paragraph 6 of HN welcoming guide: https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- wfn 11y agoI'm sorry but in this particular case I would disagree. If you google for "Palestinian territories", you end up with the wikipedia article which uses the wording "occupied territories." (As it says there) the occupation was declared "null and void" by UN security council; and Israel sovereignty "has not been recognized by any country." Noting the latter (recognition by no country), it is not just a political view but (also) a reiteration of the current state of affairs, much in the same fashion as saying that "London is the capital of the United Kingdom" (also a kind of political fact.)
- yohann305 11y agoSee, it's exactly what I don't want to happen. This is your world and what you know. Now I'm gonna have to bite your bait about "UN declaring Israel Null and void". Here is the same UN council in 1949 declaring Israel a country and part of the UN. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNVuGuX1-eo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNVuGuX1-eo
- wfn 11y agoNo, wait, there is no way one can charitably interpret what I said to extract the notion of "UN declaring Israel Null and void". UN declared the occupation of those Palestinian territories under consideration as null and void. Please, that was a very cheap trick! :) Are you saying that what I said provokes one to then start on a path which leads to statements of the kind you said (that I said)? I don't think so, as long as the principle of charity is honestly implied and applied, and the better part of the people here are not complete boneheads. Have some faith! (Notably - before, we were arguing over states of affairs and beliefs on those states; there is no reason to dismiss it as some kind of politicized regress into trash, in my opinion.)
- yohann305 11y agoAnd by the way, the first thing we learn in American Universities is to not quote Wikipedia as a source. You'd know it if you went to a higher education institution.
- wfn 11y agoBut you probably know that Wikipedia is completely fine as a reference aggregator; I was just using it as a heuristic. But now you're doing the bait thing... :(
- dang 11y agoPersonal attacks, which it seems you meant that last swipe to be, are not allowed on HN. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all.
- rdtsc 11y agoSeems pertinent in this case as it relates to technology at hand and how sanctions work. Besides 136/193 UN member states recognize the State of Palestine, more than a large majority. So saying "occupying" is not that outrageous, no?
- huac 11y ago"Mashhour Abu Daqa, a former Palestinian telecommunications minister, ... believes Israeli carriers were behind the ban, trying to protect their interest in the captive Palestinian market." this logic of economic subjugation (which I'm sure happens in other industries as well) reminds me of how the European powers treated their colonies - places to extract natural resources from and sell their surplus goods to at monopoly prices
- Papirola 11y agonot quite. carriers in Israel behaved in the same cartel fashion towards the Israeli market up until not so long ago when the government broke it: http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/business/.premium-1.651091 http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/business/.premium-1.65109... (paywall)
- andrepd 11y agoAs if there was any doubt... Only the Israeli government can cynically claim otherwise.
- Papirola 11y agoI think your understanding of the term "government" doesn't apply there. For instance there were elections in Gaza and their chosen government throws homosexuals from roofs and sanctions honor killings (among other things).
- darklajid 11y agoI think you didn't read the article, conflate Gaza with the West Banks and are far too agitated. FTA: "Israel did not extend 3G frequencies to the Gaza Strip, which is controlled by the Islamic militant group Hamas."
- AtlasLion 11y agoJust imagine the data collection on these occupier provided networks.
- Papirola 11y agohaving 2G didn't hinder their incitement attempts: http://www.timesofisrael.com/20000-israelis-sue-facebook-for-ignoring-palestinian-incitement/ http://www.timesofisrael.com/20000-israelis-sue-facebook-for... just think how much more effective their attacks will be with 3G !
- bengrunfeld 11y agoGreat, now they can commit terror with better internet speeds. Oh joy. https://youtu.be/iciOjrY_dF8 https://youtu.be/iciOjrY_dF8
- yc1010 11y agoMore likely there will be LESS terrorism as young guys spend their time watching pron and playing xbox.
- mahouse 11y ago>Grunfeld
- Papirola 11y agowhat? he forgot to wear his yellow badge?
- dang 11y agoResponding to an attack on an entire population with another attack on an entire population is the lowest thing you could have done, and this is the vilest subthread I've seen in quite a while. We're not letting HN slide any further in this direction, so if any of you wants not to be banned, don't post anything like this again.
- bengrunfeld 11y agoRight, only Israel bashing and anti-Semitism are allowed on HN. How politically correct of you.
- DanBC 11y agoYour comment is a reply to a mod comment that is telling someone posting an anti semitic slur to stop. How is that allowing Israel bashing and anti-semitism? EDIT: Go to your profile and make sure showdead is turned on. That way you can see the anti-semitic comments that have been killed by user flags and which have had comments from mods.
- cbeach 11y agoPalestinian currency is the Israeli Shekel. Palestinian capital is the Israeli city of Jerusalem. Palestinian infrastructure is provided by Israel. Palestine is a non-entity state. Its people are governed by Hamas, an Islamist protest organisation whose written charter includes the annihilation of Israel. If Palestinians stopped their terrorist attacks on Israel there would be peace. If Israel stopped defending itself militarily, it would cease to exist.
- ar7hur 11y agoNot sure how your comment relates to the posted article, but I can summarize it in 5 words: Palestine is occupied by Israel.
- cbeach 11y agoThink you'll have to justify that statement with more than five words...
- 0xexplorer 11y agoPalestine is recognised as a state by a majority of the free world. That is an undeniable fact.
- rfrey 11y agoAccording to Wikipedia, there are many states which do not recognize Palestine, including: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Liechtenstein, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Switzerland, the UK, and the USA. There are many states that do recognize Palestine, but I don't think you can claim a "majority of the free world" does. Edit: Countries in my obviously-subjective "free world" bucket that do recognize Palestine include Sweden, Iceland, Belize, South Africa, Hungary, India, and Turkey. Edit 2: I seem to be gathering disapproval, possibly because representatives of a majority of the world's population do indeed recognize Palestine. I was responding to the claim that "a majority of the free world" has recognized Palestine. Whether "the free world" is a useful designation is certainly debatable, but that was the claim in the parent post.
- tedunangst 11y agoHow long until Medium upgrades their site to require 4G?
- Zenst 11y agoWith the population density and geography, I would of thought that WIFI coverage would be more useful to the local populus and with that with WIFI and 2G you would in effect something better than 4G. I also wonnder with close proximity to other countries that the area would in parts be able to latch onto external network signals without a signal booster of any form. I know North Koreans will often go near teh CHinese border to latch onto a Chinese mobile signal for use for short calls so they can speak privately independant of their governments ears. Still, many parts of the World still to get upto 3G standard and with that, one wonders if they will get marketed old 3G cell kit that is redundant and not upgradable to later standards as todays models can do with just a code update.
- 0xexplorer 11y agoConsidering how communication links between Palestine and the rest of the world is restricted, wifi would be a moot point.
- ars 11y agoOK? How are they restricted? They are not restricted, not even to Gaza.
- 0xexplorer 11y agoThe article at the top of this page discusses the lack of access to high speed Internet in Palestine.
- ars 11y agoNo, it discusses lack of 3G mobile service. Landlines are full speed and unrestricted.
- jakobovi 11y ago"Palestinians who choose to subscribe to an Israeli mobile carrier can access 3G." The article is deceptive. Nearly all Palestinians subscribe to Israeli or European mobile carriers and have access to 4G.
- dil8 11y agoThe title should be changed from 'Palestinian territories' to 'Palestine'.
- selimthegrim 11y agoI posted this submission. The rollout is not being extended to Gaza. Moreover, pending a final settlement, this is a perfectly adequate way to refer to them seeing as even by the most pro-PLO lights they would be a successor state of Mandatory Palestine.