4 ms·
That does get into the worldview problem, yes; I have no interest in sharing a wall, ceiling, or floor, so any transportation option that only works when everyo
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
That does get into the worldview problem, yes; I have no interest in sharing a wall, ceiling, or floor, so any transportation option that only works when everyone does so does not appeal at all. That might change if apartments started coming with far more soundproofing than they currently do.
However, I wouldn't say that US major cities have good public transit; rather, they have awful automobile infrastructure such that transit looks good by comparison. And as you said, "the core of" those cities have transit options, but that doesn't mean the whole city does. I've certainly encountered much better public transit when traveling in Europe, though not sufficiently so that I'd be inclined to use it in preference.
In any case, that then leads back to the point that started this discussion: given a set of existing cities that don't have (or want) the kind of layout and design you mentioned, how do you build a transportation infrastructure? Public transit doesn't fit the current layout very well, and you can't redesign those cities from scratch even if people would prefer the new design. Hence, the many different visions of self-driving cars, which adapt more readily to various ways of laying out a city, and which work in urban, suburban, and rural settings.
- jfim 11y agoIt's a tradeoff. If you want to live in a low density area and have to drive everywhere, then no, you're not likely to have any mass transit other than a suburb commuter train to go downtown. The alternative is living in smaller, high density housing where there are two grocery stores, three coffee shops, a half dozen restaurants, a pharmacy, a metro station and so on within a five minute walking radius, and have a fifteen minute commute to work by foot or five minutes by bike, so there's not that much transit required. The funny thing is, if we go back to the point that started this discussion, the city of Montréal actually has a decent public transit system, a bike share system, 400 miles of bike paths and is one of the most bike-friendly cities in North America (depending on what source you believe). For those US cities that have low density sprawl (such as LA), there's no real way to have a transportation infrastructure that makes sense; people who are from LA will say it's fine, you just drive wherever you want, whereas Europeans will say it's not a city that you can live in because you spend your life in a car and can't go out and grab a coffee or pastry with a short walk. Self driving cars don't really solve that problem, because you'll still have thousands of people going to work at roughly the same time, and even though self-driving cars can have higher density and traffic fluidity than human-controlled ones, they still pale in comparison to mass transit systems. For example, look at Tokyo; it has at least five train stations that have a ridership over one million passengers per day and has a ridership of over forty million (granted, that number counts people switching transit systems multiple times). If you assume that the minimum surface area that a self-driving car could have is nine square feet (3x3), slightly more than a chair moving around would have, and that you need 5 million of them to have an adequate amount of service, just the surface area of all of these cars, bumper to bumper, is 1.6 square miles. Assuming you put them back to back, eight cars wide, that's 355.1 miles long worth of cars, which is about 40% of the length of freeways and highways in LA county.