3 ms·
Deciding how to balance expenses in a small corp is not a "huge scam" If it were so, then what would be the "honest" solution? Having the government tell S-Corp
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Deciding how to balance expenses in a small corp is not a "huge scam" If it were so, then what would be the "honest" solution? Having the government tell S-Corp owners what they should have paid themselves (and therefore what FICA they owe)? Having a standard FICA bill that "fairly" everyone would owe?
The more you over-complicate the system, the more things are going to happen that you personally think of as a "scam". Is a realistic solution to complicate the system further?
Put me on the side of small business owners being able to allocate payroll expenses as they see fit, and not on the side of arbitrary fees and fines to make everybody else happier, whether that's for healthcare or FICA.
- tptacek 17y agoIf we should be able to "allocate payroll expenses the way we see fit", then I'm going to "allocate" 100% of my taxes back to my bank account. Funny how that works! You've missed half the issue. These aren't people taking a $10,000 salary so they can grow their business. They're taking a $10,000 salary and a $80,000 distribution (self-employment tax is capped) and paying taxes only on the $10,000.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoCheap shot. If you do that, then it's income and you'll pay income tax, as you know. You can't get something for nothing. S-Corp profits pass through, so they hit you as income tax, not payroll tax. It's the same situation as a guy who sells apples suddenly selling a truckload of them -- it's income. Whining about how people "should" have done this or "should" have done that is all so much noise. What do you want? A forced payroll system?
- tptacek 17y agoI'm now unconvinced that you know what payroll tax is, or how S-Corps work. One of the reasons you file as an S-Corp is to W2 your income. Owners of S-Corps pay W2 like everyone else. This isn't some system where by design we designate S-Corp income as "income" and thus "exempt from payroll tax" (payroll tax being, for the most part, FICA). If it was, LLC income --- which is, for owners, entirely distributions --- wouldn't be liable for self-employment tax. This is a situation where very specifically the S-Corp designation allows people to create a channel to avoid paying FICA tax that they owe. If you have $90,000 of income and you're a small business owner, you should be paying your share whether the income is salary or distribution. You can call it "whining" and "noise" but since this practice was already an audit flag I have very little to whine about; my side of the argument already won. All I'm saying is, "good for them for closing this loophole". [Edit: you clearly do know how S-Corps work, so now I'm wondering why you're playing semantic games with the word "income".]
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI've owned an S-Corp for 15 years, I think I would know how one works. Do you or have you ever ran an S-Corp? You seem to be providing a lot of opinions. Just wondering what your credentials were. Owners of S-Corps pay off a W-2 for that portion of their income paid as payroll. The rest of it comes across on a different schedule (1120-S). I've been doing this for years. I think I know. All business arrangements have the option of how to handle excess income. Some entities may pay every penny of it to founders as W-2 income. Some may choose to pay a bit and hold the rest as savings. Some may create a bonus situation, LLCs have direct disbursements, etc. For sole proprietors and S-Corp owners, excess income (income not spent in payroll or other "legit" expenses) "flows down" to the owner, which has to pay the rest as income tax. It's not specific to S-Corps at all. The "scam", as you put it, could be as simple as the decision to hang on to some cash in the corporate account at the end of the year instead of paying payroll, or it could be the decision to use a bonus-as-disbursement system. Either one would be bypassing FICA. Or you could decide you'd rather not take a payroll for yourself. Perhaps your income is spotty, you can't afford to pay yourself minimum wage, or perhaps you can't deal with the overhead required for payrolls. Whatever. It's your decision. I'm going to bail out now -- I've played the infinite argument game with you before. I'm happy to admit fault if I don't understand this -- but I'd be really, really, really surprised if that was the case. And congrats on ducking the question I asked about solutions and instead turning the conversation to my qualifications. Makes it much less a conversation and much more a debating game.
- tptacek 17y agoWe file as an S, if you're really wondering. (You annoy me, but I think your comment is mostly in good faith [I'm pretty sure you'd rather not come out and make the honest argument, which is that you think everyone should be able to opt out of Social Security]. I voted your comment back up to "1".)
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoMeta: No, that is not my position and I do not support that position. Please do everyone a favor and try to advance the discussion instead of trying to stick your opponent in some kind of rhetorical box. I asked three questions and spent all of my bandwidth addressing your attacks on me personally instead of trying to understand/advance the discussion. The only reason I tried to talk to you was to find out what your proposed solution was. Instead I'm dancing around with you trying to justify my right to speak on the matter. That's really messed up. I don't mind getting trashed, but surely we all have better things to do here. The purpose of the board is to explain and advance issues, not score cheap points and "win" debates. It's really getting old. For the record, here are the questions I had that I never got answered: what would be the "honest" solution? Is a realistic solution to complicate the system further? What do you want? A forced payroll system? Apologies for the meta.
- karzeem 17y agoSay you're the sole shareholder of an S-Corp which, not including your salary, has $200,000 in the bank on Dec. 31. You have two ways to put that money in your pocket: either a) pay yourself a salary as an employee (say, $75,000) plus the remaining $125,000 as corporate profits, or b) just give yourself, as the sole shareholder, all $200,000 as corporate profits. With option b), significantly less money will end up in Uncle Sam's pocket. I happen to agree with you that that's a good thing, but the fact remains that the IRS considers it tax evasion. So not a good thing to engage in. S-Corp owner/employees have to pay themselves what the government agrees is a reasonable market wage before they can start banking relatively lightly taxed corporate profits.