3 ms·
This isn't censorship. You're welcome to submit the article to any site you want. I think it's a good article, and deserves to be read. But this is forum for d
by nailer 17y ago
This isn't censorship. You're welcome to submit the article to any site you want. I think it's a good article, and deserves to be read.
But this is forum for discussing technology, startups, and hacker-relevant topics.
Edit: if the article itself contains something about technology, it's clearly not the main subject, which is prisoner abuse.
- trevelyan 17y ago"It was important, he said, that servicemen make no comments or suggestions that in any way undermined the official report. He reminded the soldiers and sailors that their phone and email communications were being monitored. The meeting lasted no more than twenty minutes." ------- There is more, but you have to read the article.
- rbanffy 17y agoI find this disintegration of moral standards a very hacker-worthy issue. Hackers have been on the forefront of the defense of civil rights in a moment when technology advances much faster than the law can react to it or society can absorb it. A guy was arrested a couple days back because he jokingly vented his frustration on Twitter. Another had his face stamped on a most wanted criminals list seen around the planet because a technician found using his face would save him some work. We understand this changing technologies better than most. We can help.
- tptacek 17y agoEric Raymond finds gun control to be a very hacker-worthy issue, and firmly believes that true hackers are all libertarians. Many people clearly believe that atheism is a hacker-worthy issue, because creationists are disrupting science classes. Where does it end? Nowhere. It never ends. You let one of these stories through, you let them all through, and bang, we're Reddit.
- trevelyan 17y agoI see that this article is off the front page despite having around sixty up-votes. It has been replaced by an essay informing us that Bill Gates is on Twitter. I didn't submit this article, but I'm posting this in case you personally catch it tptacek, because I'm disappointed you've succeeded in shutting down discussion. And I'm also disappointed that a third of all comments made on this thread to date are by you and are focused on preempting discussion and accusing others of being off-topic. In most online environments that would count as trollish behavior. Downvoting and flagging is one thing and I think you're certainly in your rights to use those tools to sculpt the sorts of discussions you want to take place here. Coopting interesting and informative threads by launching trollish attacks on the relevance of the material is another. Most of the replies to your post were perfectly civil. As someone who is personally running a startup outside of the United States, I find that US policy on the War on Terror has a much stronger effect on my business (particularly through regulations affecting international money transfers, credit card processing and air travel) than a host of other issues including things like start-up visas or security vulnerabilities and other subjects you presumably consider much more on-topic given your own business. Articles that touch on these topics are on-topic to me. So even disregarding the most interesting and relevant thing about this article - the fact that military censorship of communications technologies and then FOIA blackouts apparently kept this story away from the popular media for four years - it is not irrelevant as a policy issue for a lot of people who are not you. In the future, if you want to shut down a discussion by all means flag it, but don't ruin the discussion space for those who are actually curious what others think.
- tptacek 17y agoThe military has censored communications since time immemorial. I've been a factor in a lot of discussion on Hacker News that I haven't managed to "shut down". What's shutting down this "discussion" is that there isn't anything to discuss productively. We could continue trying to provoke a fruitless discussion by extrapolating further and further from the story; "the US is evil", etc. That might pick a pointless fight. Thankfully, I think Hacker News is largely innoculated from discussions like that. The fact of the matter is that this isn't an article about how the War On Terror affects startups, and it isn't an article about censorship. If you want to have a discussion about those topics, write a blog post. It will be relevant to Hacker News, and I will vote it up.
- rbanffy 17y agoI sympathize with your worries. I too don't want HN to become another Reddit or, worse, another Digg. I feel we have a good mix of deeply technical stories and some not so, but more important, we have good discussions. Maybe the key is to keep the articles good. Nobody has the formula to prevent a successful discussion site to turn into Slashdot, Digg or Reddit. I have faith we will eventually find it. But it will be a shame if the only way to prevent a discussion site to become "uninhabitable" is by preventing certain topics. I like to think we can be mature enough.