3 ms·
> probably with partnerships like Pocket Mozilla has repeatedly stated that they're not receiving any money from bundling Pocket, and I see no reason why they
by kibwen 11y ago
> probably with partnerships like Pocket
Mozilla has repeatedly stated that they're not receiving any money from bundling Pocket, and I see no reason why they would lie about this considering that they're actively seeking to diversify revenue sources. And even if you think Mozilla is lying, there's no way that Pocket is putting up the hundreds of millions of dollars necessary to make their hypothethical contribution to Mozilla's coffers anything more than a rounding error.
- frik 11y agoI haven't read every news. I never mentioned that someone is lying!? Nor do I think that way. I just know it from Firefox, it appeared suddenly. And I had to search on Google how to get rid of this unwanted service and disable it on all family computers. I had to change settings in the hidden "about:config" - not even an UI setting was available. Why would they integrate a closed third party service to an open source browser is beyond me. It seems the responsible person had no idea what he decided and is out of touch with the product and its community.
- kibwen 11y ago> I never mentioned that someone is lying!? Sorry, when I said "even if you think" I meant "you" in the generic third-person sense, not you specifically. :)
- whyever 11y agoI never understood why they didn't just make it an add-on.
- Excavator 11y agoPocket¹, and also Hello are being migrated to extensions now. 1: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1215694 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1215694
- pdkl95 11y agoPocket is making money with their database of what people read and when they read it. This isn't insignificant. Even if there isn't some sort of payola deal going on to feed that money back to Mozilla, this is clearly being done for profit. Maybe it's some sort of indirect benefit, maybe it's someone doing a favor for a friend. The alternative isn't any better: if there isn't any benefit for Mozilla, they are letting for-profit businesses insert themselves as a feature dependency.
- Manishearth 11y ago> this is clearly being done for profit. No it isn't. The reason behind Pocket integration was thus: Firefox wanted a similar "temporary bookmark" feature to augment Reader mode and other things. Instead of coding it themselves, they decided on using an existing addon that gave the same functionality.
- pdkl95 11y agoProfit for Pocket. If they aren't making money off of their database of what people read, how are they paying for the bandwidth/hosting costs?
- Manishearth 11y agoNow you're moving around the goalposts. I was replying to "Even if there isn't some sort of payola deal going on to feed that money back to Mozilla, this is clearly being done for profit. Maybe it's some sort of indirect benefit, maybe it's someone doing a favor for a friend." There's no indirect benefit (aside from having a new feature). There's a very clear and logical reason behind the integration. In retrospect, they should have consulted with the community first perhaps, but it's false that Mozilla did this for some direct or indirect benefit.
- CaptSpify 11y agoI know I'm being a cynical ass, but I flat out do not believe that they have no incentive to integrate Pocket. Maybe it's not financial, but it has to be something. There's a lot of hate around pocket, and it provides a cool, but simple feature. Yet I haven't heard anyone who loves it and actively wants it. The best I've heard is "yeah, it's OK", even online. I don't know why they would push so hard for a product that there's so much hatred for, and nobody rooting for, whey they could just say "Wow, OK. Guess you guys don't want it. We're scrapping it". It's far from a killer feature, so who's it for?