The descriptions of Woit remind me of something I heard years ago: (paraphrased) If there's any debate about you being absolutely correct, you really can't get

The descriptions of Woit remind me of something I heard years ago: (paraphrased) If there's any debate about you being absolutely correct, you really can't get away with being an asshole. I suspect if Woit had a more friendly attitude, was less dismissive, he'd be highly regarded for his insights rather than hated.