2 ms·
Either HTTP status codes are reliable indicators of legal authorization--generally, to all observers--or they are not. Obviously they are not, since they fail t
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Either HTTP status codes are reliable indicators of legal authorization--generally, to all observers--or they are not. Obviously they are not, since they fail to identify what you acknowledge would be a clear violation.
To go back up the thread, these quotes are contradicted by the stolen password scenario:
"The canonical way people know whether they're authorized to do something to a computer system is that it allows them to do it. If you aren't authorized then it comes back with "access is denied" and you can't do it."
"Does sending an HTTP request and receiving an HTTP 200 response code indicate that you're authorized? IMO, yes."
Look, I agree that the CFAA is too vague and therefore places a chilling effect on legitimate computer science research. I'm just saying: HTTP status codes are not the answer. The answer to a problematic law is to remove or improve the law.