4 ms·
Where once logical criteria between science and non-science (or pseudo-science) were sought and taken seriously—Karl Popper’s criterion of “falsifiability” was
by noobermin 11y ago
Where once logical criteria between science and non-science (or pseudo-science) were sought and taken seriously—Karl Popper’s criterion of “falsifiability” was perhaps the most famous, insisting that a sound theory could, in principle, be proved wrong by one test or another—many historians and philosophers of science have come to think that this is a naïve view of how the scientific enterprise actually works. They see a muddle of coercion, old magical ideas, occasional experiment, hushed-up failures—all coming together in a social practice that gets results but rarely follows a definable logic.
Ugh, that "many historians or philosophers of science" comes off as the "informed sources" that conspiracy theorists claim have evidence of chemtrails or the reptilian brotherhood. Who exactly are these people and what is precisely their argument? In my opinion, this is the single greatest thing that distinguishes science from other fields, it is inductive reasoning[0] taken to an extreme. Therefore, if anyone has reason to doubt Popper's criterion, then that should be of heavy focus in the article. The author is almost guilty of "argument by inaccessible literature"[1] for what I would think is the most important part of his argument.
However, he does make an important point. Science is a human endeavour, and given that, it has issues that human institutions have. However, assuming uniformity of cognitive biases across both scientists and magicians[2], this just puts them on equal footing, while scientists have their experimental criterion, which then puts them ahead of magicians anyway.
With regards to the entanglement saga, I think the reason no one heard about it is much more mundane...there simply was no way to test it until Bell's inequality, so scientists didn't think about it. So yes, "just ignore it" was the solution because without a testable hypothesis, and may be some interesting math, scientists just don't pursue it. In that way, science might suffer due it being performed by human scientists who do have moods, but once experiment entered the picture, boy did the field blow up! I don't think it had much to do with changing attitudes as much as it came with the ability to test Bell's inequality. The same could be said about GR, with the current advances in numeric GR in the last decade spurring interest in it. It is because our moods change, but I think it has a lot more to do with the feasibility of advancement in a field that it does with external influences like the internet or cultural changes.
There are many other interesting problems with established physics, like Godel's metric[3], but, as you guessed it, you don't hear about it because there is no experimental evidence of it, so physicists look elsewhere.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning
[1] http://staffhome.ecm.uwa.edu.au/~00043886/humour/invalid.proofs.html#1.13Proofbyreferencetoinaccessibleliterature http://staffhome.ecm.uwa.edu.au/~00043886/humour/invalid.pro...
[2] (which is a scientifically testable hypothesis! but I am unqualified to give evidence for it either way
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gödel_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gödel_metric