4 ms·
> I am not convinced you have to throw common sense out the window just because you're dealing with a computer. The computer doesn't need to reject your attempt
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> I am not convinced you have to throw common sense out the window just because you're dealing with a computer. The computer doesn't need to reject your attempts to, e.g., see other peoples' account information for you to know that's outside the scope of authorized use.
It seems you're advocating for the "I know it when I see it" test.
If this common sense is so common then we can write down what it is and make sure everybody is on the same page, right?
> What you're saying is that for the specific case of computers, that presumption should be flipped: you have authorization to do whatever you're not actively prevented from doing.
The practice is flipped. In practice you are actively prevented from doing anything you aren't authorized to do, absent some flaw in the server. Why shouldn't the rule follow the practice?
- rayiner 11y ago> The practice is flipped. In practice you are actively prevented from doing anything you aren't authorized to do, absent some flaw in the server. Why shouldn't the rule follow the practice? Because it puts the burden on the property owner to secure their systems, instead of on the user to not behave in anti-social ways. In an ideal world, you wouldn't need computer security--people should just do what they're supposed to do.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> In an ideal world, you wouldn't need computer security--people should just do what they're supposed to do. It would certainly be nice if everyone in the world would just behave themselves, but then we wouldn't need computer security or laws. > Because it puts the burden on the property owner to secure their systems, instead of on the user to not behave in anti-social ways. Which would be a much stronger argument if not for the independent need to defend against foreign attackers. And once you have to have computer security because there exist people on the internet in countries with no meaningful law enforcement, the existence of that security informs expectations of how authorization works.
- tptacek 11y agoYour argument is becoming incoherent. It is because people don't behave themselves that we do need laws. The CFAA was enacted because existing wire fraud laws don't cover non- remunerative offenses, which are most serious computer offenses.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> It is because people don't behave themselves that we do need laws. And it is because people don't behave themselves that we do need computer security. So "if only the law was effective then we wouldn't need computer security" is no more accurate than "if only computer security was effective then we wouldn't need the law", except that laws have the fundamental disadvantage of not applying to attackers outside of your jurisdiction, which means that we will regardless still need computer security. > The CFAA was enacted because existing wire fraud laws don't cover non- remunerative offenses, which are most serious computer offenses. Why it was enacted has very little to do with whether it is a good law.
- harryh 11y agoNo one, at any point in this thread, has ever suggested that we don't need computer security.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10628733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10628733 > In an ideal world, you wouldn't need computer security--people should just do what they're supposed to do.
- harryh 11y agoWe do not live in an ideal world.
- 11y ago