4 ms·
Honest question: Why can't there just be non-profit banks? We don't have non-profits deliver most services because they wouldn't be efficient and/or couldn't r
by jessriedel 11y ago
Honest question: Why can't there just be non-profit banks?
We don't have non-profits deliver most services because they wouldn't be efficient and/or couldn't raise capital from investors. And once investor come in, their profits are taxed. But there's nothing that in-principally stops a charitable organization from opening a non-profit car repair shop which runs with no net profit.
If, for whatever reason, it's feasible for non-profit banks to get started and operate successfully, why would we not allow them? (Please put "because the legislators are bought-off"-type arguments aside. What are the reasons people give?)
Are grocery co-ops limited in membership?
- gluelogic 11y agoWhy put those arguments aside when it seems like that is the primary reason why non-profit banks can not exist?
- jessriedel 11y agoIt's a logically separate issue. One discussion at a time.
- rayiner 11y agoI'm not aware of any law precluding not-for-profit banks. E.g. USAA's banking arm is a quasi not-for-profit bank: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/in-the-era-of-greed-meet-americas-good-bank-usaa/252161 http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/in-the-e....
- jessriedel 11y agoThis is a very useful example, thank you. What exactly is the benefit credit unions derive from satisfying the legal requirement of credit unions, rather than just following the sort of incorporation that USAA uses? Can't they avoid taxes on corporate income by just running with negligible profit? EDIT: So I'm reading through your link above. They mention the obvious way that nominally for-profit corporations could run at zero-profit by returning all excess funds in the form of interest to depositors: > In contrast, mutual corporations are owned by their depositors, and the equity of a mutual corporation is derived solely from retained earnings. Because depositors are the owners, payments to depositors can include both interest and an equity return to depositors in their role as owners. While depository institutions are generally permitted to deduct interest paid on deposits, mutual thrifts are also allowed a deduction for amounts paid or credited to their depositors as dividends on their accounts, including amounts that represent an equity return, if such amounts may be withdrawn on demand subject only to customary notice of intention to withdraw. Why don't credit unions just become non-profit and do this?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Honest question: Why can't there just be non-profit banks? There can be. If you mean, why can't there be "tax-exempt non-profit banks", the reason is because the tax code doesn't allow it (though no-capital-stock member-owned banks seem to be effectively untaxed, except on transactions subsidized by federal assistance to such banks, if they actually distribute their operating surplus to demand deposit accounts of the members.) > We don't have non-profits deliver most services because they wouldn't be efficient and/or couldn't raise capital from investors. If you are referring to "tax exempt non-profits", we don't have them deliver most services because there are limited categories in tax law of tax-exempt non-profits.
- jessriedel 11y agoI must be unaware of an important distinction here. Non-profits don't pay taxes, so non-profit banks are automatically tax-exempt, right? (Put aside issues of tax-exempt status of donations to non-profits; credit unions don't take donations.) Maybe here's another way to formulate my question: why can't a credit union operate as a for-profit bank, but just structure their company so that it's committed to never earning a profit and hence never paying much taxes? (It's perfectly legal for corporations to pursue ends besides maximizing shareholder value, so long as they are publicly disclosed, popular misconceptions notwithstanding.) In other words, why do credit unions bother to satisfy the legal requirements of being credit unions?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Non-profits don't pay taxes, so non-profit banks are automatically tax-exempt, right? Tax-exempt non-profits are a subset of organizations not organized for profit. To be tax-exempt, an organization must not only be not-organized-for-profit, it must also meet the qualifications of one of an enumerated list of categories of tax-exempt non-profits in the Internal Revenue Code. > Maybe here's another way to formulate my question: why can't a credit union operate as a for-profit bank Because then it would be a "bank" and not a "credit union". > but just structure their company so that it's committed to never earning a profit and hence never paying much taxes? An organization structured like that is a mutual savings bank; as the return of surpluses via demand accounts (the same way a credit union typically returns surpluses) is tax deductible for them, as discussed upthread, it is quite possible to have a bank (rather than a credit union) that returns surpluses to members like a credit union and is effectively untaxed (it looks like a mutual savings bank that didn't retain surplus profits would be untaxed except on things for which it received federal subsidies as a mutual savings bank.) > Why do credit unions bother to satisfy the legal requirements of being credit unions? Because the legal requirements for starting a bank are pretty hard, too (whether legitimately to protect people from bad banks, or as protectionism through regulatory capture by incumbents, whatever, the barriers are there), so while the rules are slightly different for credit unions, you don't actually make your job easier by trying to start a bank-to-operate-like-a-credit-union.