3 ms·
The article seems to assume that social factors like product prevalence should have no bearing on the actual ultimate economic benefits of the dominant player,
by cookiecaper 17y ago
The article seems to assume that social factors like product prevalence should have no bearing on the actual ultimate economic benefits of the dominant player, and that's silly, in my opinion.
We've only seen it more and more often; something may be technically better, but there's more than technical consideration in choosing a product, and if the newer product can't overcome the social inertia associated with the old product, then it doesn't offer a net benefit.
People choose PHP because there is an abundance of PHP programmers and businessmen want to stiff people on pay more than they want a good interpreter running their software.
People choose Windows because the system is familiar and all of the software they know, often niche, rare, or unmaintained, works correctly on it.
And so on.
And then there are instances where the consumers don't really have much say, like Blu-ray v. HD-DVD. They were well about even until the one supergiant corporation (Sony) swooped in with extra incentives for the other supergiant corporations (movie sudios) to get them to choose Blu-ray over HD-DVD, even though HD-DVD is ultimately superior.
So I sympathize with their intention to preserve faith in free markets, but their postulation that markets always make the right choice technically is silly. There are many other factors, including retraining costs, meddling by big players, etc., that can effect the ultimate dominance of a product.
- j_baker 17y agoI don't necessarily agree with the idea, but there is an economic theory that essentially states that the market is always right given that it has perfect information. You can agree or disagree with that theory, but I don't think what they're saying is necessarily absurd.
- zck 17y agoEven if you hold that theory, there's an implicit limit as t->infinity. Certainly if a new keyboard that's objectively better was introduced today, by tomorrow it wouldn't have >50% marketshare.
- joblessjunkie 17y agoI disagree that this article assumes that product prevalence has "no bearing at all". That would be silly. Rather, I think it merely demonstrates that product prevalence is not the only factor, and often not even the most important one. It dismisses the popular delusion that early success is all that is required to become an entrenched, inferior monopoly. When high profile figures with political influence fall prey to these delusions -- even in the face of contrary evidence -- it bears a detailed criticism.