4 ms·
> The issue of slowing rents is most acute in Seattle neighborhoods that are experiencing an unprecedented amount of development, according to Dupre + Scott Apa
by Zigurd 11y ago
> The issue of slowing rents is most acute in Seattle neighborhoods that are experiencing an unprecedented amount of development, according to Dupre + Scott Apartment Advisors. The Seattle apartment tracking firm said that rents rose 5.6 percent region-wide from March through September, and were up 8.3 percent from a year prior.
How odd to think of housing as something that should always go up in price.
- pc86 11y agoIf it doesn't then there is almost no legitimate financial reason to buy a house. Nobody will buy a $200k house if chances are it will be worth $180-220k in 40 years before inflation.
- Jach 11y agoThere's still two big reasons I can see: a place to live and for your children to inherit, and a place to rent out.
- davmre 11y agoThe reason to buy a house would be the same as the reason to buy a car, or any other item: because you want to use it. If housing prices are guaranteed to increase, it means owners of housing are extracting unearned rents from the economy. Houses decay over time and eventually need to be renovated/rebuilt, so you should on average take a net loss from owning and occupying a house, just as you would a car.
- refurb 11y agoThe difference between a car and house is the house can't be replaced, a car can. If someone wants to live in San Francisco, they can't just substitute it by living in Portland. If more people want to live in San Francisco, then the price goes up due to the limited supply.
- theseatoms 11y agoThe land itself cannot be replaced. The physical house that sits on the land can.
- refurb 11y agoTrue, but most of the value is in the land. A derelict house in San Francisco is worth over $1M, but $800K+ is the land.
- theseatoms 11y agoYes, San Francisco is fairly unique in this regard.
- nasalgoat 11y agoNot really, it's the same thing here in Toronto. Developers regularly buy tear-down bungalows on 50' x 120' lots for $1.2M and proceeds to put two tiny houses on the lot that sell for $1M each.
- theseatoms 11y agoThere are a variety of reasons to buy a house. One is to use, or consume, the shelter that it provides. As a human, you'll always be a "natural buyer" of shelter. (Though not necessarily always where you own shelter.) Another reason to own property is to speculate on the valuation of the land or the house itself. These two aspects of home ownership are very often conflated. It's actually shocking how infrequently this distinction is discussed, especially given how common home ownership is.
- apalmer 11y agoOK? I dont mean to be snarky but financial investment isn't necessarily the ultimate motivator for all things. Also fundamentally, we are talking rental property, rental income is a legitimate financial reason to buy rental property. Spend 5 million today, rent out for 500k a year, make your money back after 10 years, literally get money for nothing for every year after that... thats not a good enough financial reason? basically real estate is a very slow moving ponzi scheme, perhaps one can argue its a ponzi scheme that cant fail as long as the human population continues to increase.
- refurb 11y agothats not a good enough financial reason? Your scenario (buy for $5M, rent for $500K/yr) actually sounds quite terrible. At even nominal interest rates you're probably paying 150% of the purchase price, so you won't breakeven until almost 15 years in. And with the time value of money, making a big investment now for $500K per year 15 years from now must be an absolutely awful return. I do see your point thought. There is nothing wrong with buying a house because you want it. However, that's not why most people buy houses (at least in the US). There is the pervasive perception that housing is a "good investment".
- pyoung 11y agoYou are still building equity as opposed to throwing money away to a landlord. And there are a lot of other intangibles such as stability (no more rent increases or evictions) and freedom to modify/alter/improve the property. These are probably much more important features to potential home owners (especially ones considering/having children). And another thing to consider, for most homeowners a hot real estate market only benefits them if they are willing to move to a lower priced market or downsize their home. Moving laterally or trying to upgrade during a hot market means you are exposed to the same percentage of price increases as everyone else. The only people that really benefit from hot real estate markets are investors and landlords.
- refurb 11y agoYou are still building equity as opposed to throwing money away to a landlord. That's a fallacy. Whether or not you rent a place (pay another person to buy it) or you buy it yourself, buying is not always better than renting. There are many situations where if you rented your whole life you'd be better off than owning, even assuming housing appreciates. I was renting (after owning for many years) right before the housing crash in 2008. I paid ~$30K to rent a place over two years. I know folks who bought who lost 3 times that owning a house. When I wanted to move I just gave the keys back. The landlord took the hit, not me.
- dionidium 11y agoThere is no such thing as throwing money away to a landlord, unless you also believe that every other case in which you use money to buy something you desire is "throwing money away."
- Jtsummers 11y agoWhether it's throwing money away or not depends on the future value of the good, expected duration of ownership, and the utilization rate. Same as the purchase versus rent decision on every other purchase.
- enjo 11y agoI'd still buy the house. A 30 year mortgage on that $200k house @ 6% is going to cost me $1,199 a month or $431,676 over the life of that mortgage. If the house devalues to $180k my actual out of pocket money spent is $251,676. If I do a 15 year mortgage under the same conditions I spend $1,688 a month, but my total cash out is down to $303,788 over the life of the loan or $123,788 out of pocket (again assuming the house is worth $180k in the end). Now lets pretend like I can find rent at $1k a month for something similar. That's unlikely to be true over that period (rents tend to rise at least with inflation), but lets just go with it. Over a 30 year period I will have spent $360,000. That's $108,324 more than my 30 year mortgage and a whopping $236,212 over my 15 year mortgage. That's not even counting the interest deductions I get to take on the mortgage interest I'm paying. Now I know I'm discounting a bunch of things like property taxes and maintenance on the house (in return I'm giving unrealistically low rent). Those costs for your average house aren't going to be anywhere near the difference in rent... If you're relatively stable in your life, buying almost always makes more sense than renting because at the end of the day you have to pay someone to live somewhere and some of that might as well end up in your bank account.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoAnother way to put it would be that the future appreciation is priced in at purchase time. If the asset is not expected to appreciate, its price will be less.
- revelation 11y agoI don't get it, you lived in it for 40 years. Why would it be worth more? Do you buy food?
- joesmo 11y agoWhat about living in that house and retiring in it? You definitely can't rent in many places on social security payments. Though of course that requires taxes to at least be affordable on social security, something that isn't true in a lot of places.