4 ms·
No but the point is a mouse simply does not have the capacity to understand French. Maybe humans do not have the capacity to understand the complete workings o
by jstanley 11y ago
No but the point is a mouse simply does not have the capacity to understand French.
Maybe humans do not have the capacity to understand the complete workings of physics.
- trhway 11y ago>a mouse simply does not have the capacity to understand French. we don't really know what capacity is required to do it. 1PFlops? 1P neuron synapse transfers/minute? What capacity and in what units mouse brain is? Our human brain evolution has abused low efficiency size increase approach. As result we're using only like 10% of capacity of our brain. This dog knows 1000 words in human language. That's more than i know in Chinese, and the task of learning a 1000 Chinese hieroglyphs scares the hell out of me: https://www.thedodo.com/worlds-smartest-dog-chaser-752002926.html https://www.thedodo.com/worlds-smartest-dog-chaser-752002926... >Maybe humans do not have the capacity to understand the complete workings of physics. why would it be so? So far the physics has been pretty simple (any abnormal complexity has been usually an indication of our lack of understanding and has been successfully cleared with time) , and even several orders of magnitude complexity increase will fit into our brain. Edit: to the comment below on 10% - there is a difference between 10% capacity and 10% neurons. The fact that most of our brain is physiologically participating while producing that little capacity most of the time in most of the people is exactly the low efficiency i was talking about.
- Ygg2 11y ago> As result we're using only like 10% of capacity of our brain. This myth needs to die in a fire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_percent_of_the_brain_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_percent_of_the_brain_myth
- _kst_ 11y agoIt's been said (I don't know how accurately) that some people do use 100% of their brains. They just happen to be in the midst of a grand mal epileptic seizure.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> This dog knows 1000 words in human language. That's more than i know in Chinese, and the task of learning a 1000 Chinese hieroglyphs scares the hell out of me. Okay; but that dog can't have a conversation. It doesn't know what they mean, it just knows that follows a certain stimulus. It's like saying I understand cloud language, because I can tell when it's going to rain after looking at the sky. And even if that dog "understands" a thousand words, and you're scared of learning a thousand Chinese characters, you still have the capacity for learning Chinese. Or French. Or Spanish, or Esperanto, or Russian, or Thai. You could spend a year learning Russian, and we could have this conversation in that language; I will never be able to explain this conversation to a dog, in any language.
- trhway 11y ago>Okay; but that dog can't have a conversation. dogs do have conversations. And other animals too. Check the link on the prairie dogs for example. >I will never be able to explain this conversation to a dog, in any language. it is the deficiency of human-to-dog communication, not the dog's lack of mental capacity to handle the complexity of conversation.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoChinese characters are not 'hieroglyphs.'
- Govannon 11y agoAnd they are logograms, or at least they compose a logographic system.
- PKop 11y agoDoes the dog have the capacity to understand how the universe works? Does the dog have the capacity to understand physics to the degree that we understand it now? No. So the dog has its limits, as we have ours. Where the limits are is certainly up for debate, but hard to believe there is no limit.
- gnaritas 11y ago> to the comment below on 10% - there is a difference between 10% capacity and 10% neurons. The fact that most of our brain is physiologically participating while producing that little capacity most of the time in most of the people is exactly the low efficiency i was talking about. And still no. Phrase it however you like, it's still wrong. You are not using just 10% of your brain in any manner or means, there is not some great untapped potential waiting to be turned on, your brain is not low efficiency.
- Freaky 11y agoYou'd probably be better off linking to something like this: http://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=6116 http://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=6116 Or this: http://rifters.com/real/2009/01/iterating-towards-bethlehem.html http://rifters.com/real/2009/01/iterating-towards-bethlehem.... Less than a million neurons and Portia's interpreting complex visual scenes and making detailed attack plans. While "we only use 10% of our brains" is clearly bollocks, the implication that our brains may not be particularly efficient for our level of intelligence doesn't seem too unlikely given the way evolution works - our brain's a crudely scaled-up pile of accidental hacks guided by endless local maxima it can't readily escape from, it'd be very surprising if you couldn't improve on it. You might draw parallels with modern computers. All these transistors to play with, but we're certainly not using them as well as we could - we're limited by the software we want to run and know how to write using our existing tools.
- wlievens 11y agoBut that could only be the case if those laws are very, very complicated. So far physical laws have been on the side of "understandable if you invest a couple years of study as a reaonably intelligent person".
- jp555 11y agoDoes a human have the capacity to understand the complete workings of an Intel CPU? I doubt it. But we augment our capacities with tools, something mice don't do.