3 ms·
Yes, we're seeing this theme a lot in the news. "X was a refugee too!" Unfortunately, it's pretty much the same class of statement as "Hitler (hated smoking|lo
by SilasX 11y ago
Yes, we're seeing this theme a lot in the news. "X was a refugee too!"
Unfortunately, it's pretty much the same class of statement as "Hitler (hated smoking|loved his mother|was a vegeterian|built good highways) too! How about that!" albeit with a more sympathetic group of people.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- meesterdude 11y agoactually, it's incredibly relevant. it's to show that refugees are people too, and are not incapable of leading to good and prosperous things. that you think they are trying to say he did what he did because he was an immigrant, or that all immigrants will be great, shows you fundamentally misunderstand the point; or maybe you have other feelings about the matter that cloud your perspective.
- appleflaxen 11y agoI don't think your analogy is accurate. "this is an overall good quality" is not disproved by the existence of one bad person who happens to possess that quality. But "all refugees should be sent back to where they came from" is disproven by the existence of one virtuous refugee.
- SilasX 11y agoThat's stacking the deck just the same. You could likewise frame it was a comparison between "everything Hitler liked was bad" and "every refugee should be admitted" (and no matter how much you like refugees, you're eventually going to get to the point of turning one down).
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> But "all refugees should be sent back to where they came from" is disproven by the existence of one virtuous refugee. Only if you also accept that "we should admit everyone who is virtuous". That is not a universally accepted assumption...