4 ms·
Sure. Now ask yourself where you'd rather invest in property: in the USA, Russia, China. If you answer "China", "Russia", or "It doesn't matter", you're also in
by tomcam 11y ago
Sure. Now ask yourself where you'd rather invest in property: in the USA, Russia, China. If you answer "China", "Russia", or "It doesn't matter", you're also in denial. Because the current real estate bubble is being driven largely by foreign nationals who are putting their money where their freedom is, and they are not choosing Russia or China.
The article is well worth reading. It makes some truly provocative points, but in real life we have to choose between unpleasant options, not an unattainable theoretical place and unpleasant options.
- Retric 11y agoThat's something of a false dichotomy as there are many other options. However, diminishing returns kicks in so you eventually start making risky investments.
- johnchristopher 11y agoI have to ask: is something going on regarding real estate and Chinese investors in SF or California ? It's not the first time I read hints about it on HN.
- chucksmash 11y agoOverseas investors buying up property in NYC as a way to park money comes up as well.
- eru 11y agoIt's also common in London.
- rconti 11y agoYes? They've been buying property for some time now. Not just in the US, but in Canada (Vancouver in particular). Same with Russians buying property in the UK. I'm not sure what you found controversial or surprising in the parent comment, though I haven't read the article because holy dense TLDR.
- Spooky23 11y agoCapital is fleeing places like China and is being converted to real estate assets. Real estate is seen as more secure than Chinese currency, and it's easy to transfer real estate while remaining fairly anonymous and avoiding money laundering laws.
- tomcam 11y agoYes. Also Vancouver & Northern Cal. Have Chinese family & am involved in a fair amount of real estate. For reasons I don't quite understand, real estate people are too polite to say that the vast majority of cash transactions in some areas such as Vancouver, Seattle, and Silicon Valley are from China (and Russian in other areas).
- johnchristopher 11y agoThanks everyone, I am not living in the US so I am not really up to date with local real estate realities.
- umanwizard 11y agoDid we read the same article? What does this have anything to do with it?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI believe that tomcam's point is that "the rule of law", though it plays out imperfectly in the US, still is effective enough to really matter.
- jxramos 11y agoMakes me think about the Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto who did some interesting experiments to show how good property laws and what not directly relate to wealth generation. http://www.thepowerofthepoor.com/concepts/c6.php http://www.thepowerofthepoor.com/concepts/c6.php Globalization at the Crossroads (DVD) Globalization at the Crossroads features renowned Peruvian economist and author, Hernando de Soto. His twenty years of research show that economies prosper only in places where widespread personal property ownership exists—coupled with inclusive, efficient, and transparent business and property law.
- umanwizard 11y agoBut the law is just as much of a state monopoly in Russia and China as it is here... Also it's a complete non sequitur. There are so many differences between Russia, China, and the U.S. that it's absurd to point to one area in which the U.S. is winning and claim it's because of our particular system of law, as opposed to any number of other factors.
- EliRivers 11y agoLaw may be a monopoly of the state in the US, but it's not something that the state is guaranteed to always have the best of. In Russia and China, if "the government" (however we interpret that) wants something, it gets it. In the US (and many other places), it can be found to be unlawful and the government doesn't get it.
- tomcam 11y ago