3 ms·
Nuclear is not really low carbon when you take into account the amount of concrete you need to build a modern reactor. Unless we have a major breakthrough in m
by danieltillett 11y ago
Nuclear is not really low carbon when you take into account the amount of concrete you need to build a modern reactor.
Unless we have a major breakthrough in mining uranium or we actually manage to make breeder reactors safe and cost effective then nuclear is not really a viable option.
Edit. I should have been more precise in my language. By low carbon I am meaning minimal carbon, not just lower carbon. Natural gas is lower carbon, but it is not low carbon.
It really doesn't matter too much because there just isn't enough uranium to make it a viable alternative at the scale we need to have a significant impact on carbon emissions.
- XorNot 11y agoIn the time honoured tradition of shooting ourselves in the foot by making better the enemy of best? Neither concrete, nor uranium mining have to burn fossil fuels (and CO2 sequesting concrete is a real thing). They are decoupled from their fuel source, but the lack of incentives to improve that situation at present (due to the near entirety of electrical generation being fossil fuels) is the bigger problem.
- danieltillett 11y agoMaking cement by its nature releases a large amount of CO2 and accounts for 5% of total emissions [1]. I do agree that we are not really creating the right incentives to improve things. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_concrete https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_conc...
- XorNot 11y agoBut note from that page: energy use is 40% of the CO2 expense of concrete. So assume we can pretty much eliminate that by other means. That leaves a 50% chunk due to chemistry. For that we have things like eco-cement, or carbon sequestration technologies.
- vonmoltke 11y agoIn addition to what XorNot7 said, the amount of concrete needed to build a nuclear power plant is trivial compared to the total amount consumed annually by the construction industry.
- xigency 11y ago> Nuclear is not really low carbon when you take into account the amount of concrete you need to build a modern reactor. That sounds really preposterous.
- DennisP 11y agoIt's less than the concrete for an equivalent amount of wind power. Neither is all that significant compared to fossil fuels.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt is not just the the total mass of concrete needed, it is the technical requirements and the difficulty of building the nuclear structures that uses massive amounts of carbon derived energy.
- DennisP 11y agoI'd like to see specific numbers on how that difficulty translates into carbon emissions. Estimates I've seen that showed large CO2 emissions from nuclear were wildly overblown. In one case, they assumed that nuclear power would lead to full-scale nuclear war and included the carbon impact of the war. In any case, if the NRC would let companies start building molten salt reactors, we could have much simpler construction. For starters, they'd be at atmospheric pressure, eliminating the need for large steel-reinforced containment domes and high-pressure reactor vessels. We could mass-produce reactors in factories or shipyards.
- danieltillett 11y ago>I'd like to see specific numbers on how that difficulty translates into carbon emissions. So would I. Getting good data in this area is near impossible. For something complex you can use the rough rule of thumb that the dollar cost is proportional to the emissions - as complexity increases the actual emissions converge towards the economy wide average. On this basis the emissions from building a current generation nuclear power plant is very high.
- DennisP 11y agoNuclear plants cost a lot up front but they produce a lot of power for a long time. Per MWh they're not that expensive compared to renewables. Taking the government's estimates for capital cost, we have onshore wind at $58/MWh, nuclear at $70/MWh, hydro $71, advanced coal $77, solar PV $109, offshore wind $168, solar thermal $192. But I don't think anyone would claim that the construction of a modern coal plant has significant emissions compared to actually burning the coal. https://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/electricity_generation.cfm https://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/electricity_generation.cfm