4 ms·
I'd think there are better sources for reading about climate change than an author one who must admit "I didn’t mention nuclear because I don’t know much about
by jessriedel 11y ago
I'd think there are better sources for reading about climate change than an author one who must admit "I didn’t mention nuclear because I don’t know much about it."
- jf 11y agoWhat would you recommend?
- ommunist 11y agoWhen it comes to real climate change data - nothing can substitute glaciology data. This is a good graph for you. Holocene temperature variations. Ironically it was quite warmer just 8 thousand years ago. Look, no cars, no cows, no industry... and it _was warmer_.
- skadamat 11y agoThe guy has a MS in Electrical Engineering and knows his stuff. Bret maybe just doesn't want to discuss topics he knows little about. Doesn't mean the rest of the manifesto is somehow broken :)
- vox_mollis 11y agoYou consider an author honestly assessing the scope and limitations of his own knowledge, and disclosing it, a negative? Really? I'd wager that a good chunk of our problems today originates from policymaking on the basis of people who don't know, or don't admit, what they don't know.
- skadamat 11y agoSpot on!
- jessriedel 11y agoHuh? I'm not criticizing the inclusion of that sentence, I'm criticizing the claimed scope of the piece. It's great to know lots of stuff about renewable energy, but its impossible to have a sufficiently informed opinion on climate change to start making claims about how our industrial society should re-tool without knowing about nuclear. Proper intellectual modesty does not shield you from this. If the author wrote a long piece about how the best way to solve climate change was to quintuple the number of nuclear power plants and mentioned "I really don't know much about the solar industry", would you consider that an authoritative piece? Should we be reading it?
- nanny 11y agoGet lost. You're using a textbook ad hominem argument, while the author you're talking about has boatloads of evidence and put a lot of work into this page, and you think it's bad thing that he's humble enough to admit that he was a lack of knowledge on one particular topic? That just boggles my mind.
- hueving 11y agoHow so? Does the author not suggest the elimination of nuclear even though he has no knowledge of it?
- dang 11y ago> Get lost. Please don't do this on HN. Comments here need to be civil. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html