5 ms·
The same thing is being mentioned in several places elsewhere, but to put some numbers on it: Orbital velocity is in the vicinity of 7500 to 8000 m/s. At that
by ColinWright 11y ago
The same thing is being mentioned in several places elsewhere, but to put some numbers on it:
Orbital velocity is in the vicinity of 7500 to 8000 m/s. At that speed your KE is 1/2.m.v^2 which is about 32e6 Joules/kg.
Orbits are, conveniently, at about 320 km, so your PE is m.g.h, or about about 3.2e6 Joules/kg.
In other words, the energy to get to orbit is ten times the energy to get to the altitude of orbit, and this exercise only got to 1/3 of that. So the energy involved was about 1/30 of that required to put something in orbit.
It's still a fantastic achievement, and an important - nay, critical - step on the way to properly reusable rockets, but it does lend some perspective to it.
- cmsmith 11y agoComparing one- and two- stage rockets is a bit of a handicap, since no one (yet) is talking about landing a single-stage-to-orbit rocket. The best numbers I can find say that the Falcon 9 stage separation is at around 80km and 2km/sec (2.8 MJ/kg of total energy), and the Falcon 9 has so far failed to land under power.
- ColinWright 11y agoYes, there are lots of subtleties about staging and so forth, but lots of people are talking about that elsewhere. I just thought I'd put some number to the simplest possible case so people can see the magnitudes we're talking about.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoThat's neat. But what I see on video is Bezos landing a rocket and Musk blowing up a rocket. I understand the technical differences, but in terms of media, this is a pure win.
- rakoo 11y agoWhat I see is Musk supplying the ISS, and Bezos doing a PR stunt. Let's try comparing those on more than just media, shall we ?
- fixermark 11y agoPerhaps, perhaps not. Financially speaking, between the two goals, there's enough money concentrated in private individuals' hands that you might be able to find six people willing to shell out for space tourism. Government funding supplies the ISS. A laudable goals, but there's a grim realpolitik view that suggests it's not as guaranteed sustainable of a market as space tourism. On the other hand, SpaceX's goals also allow for deployment of orbital payloads... Now that's lucrative.
- nightpool 11y agoThere are plenty of videos of Musk successfully landing a rocket? Just never actually landing one from orbit.
- jacquesm 11y agoNo-one has managed a landing from orbit. Yet.
- tillinghast 11y agoIt would be a breakthrough of Gaussian proportions!
- tertius 11y ago* Excluding your "media win" part of the comment. Parallel parking a Prius vs. parking a dragster is different. But as you said, you understand the technical differences.
- paraboul 11y agoSpaceX already achieved suborbital VTOL in 2013 : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t15vP1PyoA&app=desktop https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2t15vP1PyoA&app=desktop
- chillingeffect 11y agoNot that I have any skin in the game - I think Musk and Bezos are both insufferable billionaire jerks, scamming taxpayers and working the lower class to death - but Grasshopper went to 250m, while Blue Origin went to 100km.
- baq 11y agoit's not that much of a difference, going almost straight up and falling mostly straight down is a matter of burning longer. it is an achievement, it's just not useful for much (for the price) and overengineered at that. if it actually went to orbit and didn't come back, it'd be a bigger thing.
- ra88it 11y ago>> That's neat. You make a very good point about public perception. But your opening line seems sarcastic and aggressive. I think that's why your comment is light grey.
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoTLDR: Blue Origin did a soft landing from above the Karman line. SpaceX is trying to do that from orbit. The former involves speeds 10x less and energies 100x less than the latter. Still a hard thing to do no matter how you look at it, but the two goals are not trivial to compare.
- ecobiker 11y agoI see so many people complaining about the comparison but no explained it more clearly, thanks! Quick question though, isn't SpaceX trying to land just the first stage?
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoI believe they want to eventually land and recover all pieces.
- jccooper 11y agoWell, kind of. The F9-1 would be on it's way to orbit, but not there. It's a first stage after all. It would certainly have much higher energy, and is huge in comparison.