2 ms·
TDD has always looked to me like a good idea taken to ridiculously dogmatic extremes (a very common occurrence in software development, IMHO), but I think many
by mannykannot 11y ago
TDD has always looked to me like a good idea taken to ridiculously dogmatic extremes (a very common occurrence in software development, IMHO), but I think many of this author’s indiscriminate potshots miss the most important problems.
In order to write a test for something, you need to know what it is supposed to do, and testing will not tell you that. In order to make something that passes your tests, you have to design it, and a test does not tell you what that design should be - it can tell you if you failed in a specific way, but not what to do about it. There is a whole lot of analytical reasoning and technical judgement to software development that is ignored by TDD, and while thinking about test cases can help with this, it is an insufficiently powerful method to complete the job.
Agile methods have not rescinded this fact. Insofar as they form a complete development methodology (and I am not sure about that), they offer an empirical approach to discovering your requirements (which may or may not be appropriate to your situation), and the use of short-cycle iteration to gauge how you are progressing, but they are largely silent on the issues I raised above.