3 ms·
Such a bug didn't deserve the snarkiness it got; as the article author notes, Linux itself remains a minor platform for end users, and benefits from people doin
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Such a bug didn't deserve the snarkiness it got; as the article author notes, Linux itself remains a minor platform for end users, and benefits from people doing ports to Linux of software that has more users on other platforms. (For instance, Firefox and Chrome both have far more users on Windows than Linux.) But apart from the unnecessarily snarky response, I think this played out exactly as it should have. A kinder response would have been "none of us run OpenBSD, but if you can provide a non-invasive patch, we'll merge it". Which ended up happening anyway.
- rewqfdsa 11y ago> Linux itself remains a minor platform for end users What the fuck? Android is one of the most popular operating systems in the world.
- biot 11y agoThat's a bit like saying that all Xbox users should count towards Windows numbers.
- umanwizard 11y agoWhen people say linux, they don't care what kernel they're running - they mean GNU/Linux that has a reasonably close interface to that of a typical UNIX machine. I agree with Stallman &co. that the name "Linux" is imprecise, but you shouldn't pretend you don't understand what people mean.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoAndroid systems don't run normal Linux binaries; Android has an incompatible ABI, not least of which because it puts the dynamic linker in a different location (and compiles that different location into every single binary). It shares the same kernel, but with a completely different userspace, and typically requires a separate effort to port. (I'd have said "GNU/Linux" to avoid the ambiguity if I didn't think it'd massively and pointlessly derail the conversation. In particular, given the nature of this thread, it seemed needlessly adversarial.)
- mrweasel 11y agoGoogle patches the snot out of the Linux kernel in Android. In fact in now contains a fair amount of ideas from OpenBSD. Theo De Raadt talks about some of the in his Pledge talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_7S1eqKsFk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_7S1eqKsFk
- toadkicker 11y agoThis is the way good things get done. New ideas should come from anywhere they can and the best ones bubble up into the product. Always reset expectations if anything that does get said ends up being misread. Let's face it; text is a horrible medium for communicating complex ideas. Open the communication channel accepting things at face value.