4 ms·
Before you jump in with outrage or bafflement, consider that this isn't all that shocking, nor is having to pay a bank to keep your money totally unprecedented.
by Analemma_ 11y ago
Before you jump in with outrage or bafflement, consider that this isn't all that shocking, nor is having to pay a bank to keep your money totally unprecedented. Consider: if you want someone else to store your car, or your junk, or your data, you have to pay them. The only reason banks normally pay you instead is that your deposits are so useful (for making loans, and profit on those loans), that it's worth it to pay you to convince you to put your money there. But if economic conditions are such that the bank can't make any profit using your money, there's no reason why they would pay you to keep it there.
You might ask, why on earth would I pay a negative interest rate on deposits if I can just keep my money under my mattress? And yes, you could do that, and some people will (or they'll move to a different bank). But then you can't pay with debit cards or use any of the other services provided by a bank, or benefit from its physical security. Those things do cost the bank money which has to be paid somehow, it was just hidden from you by the interest rate.
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt isn't utterly unprecedented either. Banks used to charge fees for holding your money (though interest could make that back and large balances might have got them waived). Free banking for all is a recent development.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Free banking for all is a recent development. Even just plain banking for all is a not-yet-achieved state (much less free banking for all.) [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked
- quotequad 11y ago"Consider: if you want {to let} someone else {drive around in} your car {and rent it out to other people} ... you have to pay them." Excuse me?
- Analemma_ 11y agoI was just referring to storage, like in a parking garage or something. Sorry if my run-on sentence made it a little obtuse :-)
- theheck 11y agoYou're correct that if someone has to store a physical item (like a car), there are costs related to storage. In the case of 21st century currency, however, almost none of your money actually exists in physical cash [1], the vast majority simply exists as accounting entries, stored as digits in computers (seriously). Traditional banking typically consists of two SEPARATE functions. 1) The first function is the safe-keeping of deposits (for which a fee would normally be assessed as an actual commodity (gold, silver, etc.) would be stored, and you have to pay rent, security, etc. related to the safekeeping of that commodity). 2) The second function is loan intermediation (that is, matching up people who want to invest their money with people who want to borrow it -- as an investor you would receive a return on your money less fees assessed by the bank for determining who should receive loans). Certificates of Deposit (CDs) are the classic example of a bank engaging in this second function. CDs require you to relinquish your ability to withdraw your deposits for an agreed upon term. Modern banking, however, muddles these two functions. Paper bills no longer represent specific quantities of physical commodities held for safe-keeping by the bank. They simply represent themselves, pieces of paper that people continue to accept as money because they were slowly weaned off of using physical commodities. Further, banks are allowed to simultaneously loan out the money you have sitting in a savings account (and pay you interest on it) but also give it to you in physical cash should you demand it. How can it be that your cash could be in two places at the same time (invested in a loan but also available for withdrawal)? If you loaned your car to a bank, and they lent it out to someone else, could it simultaneously be available for retrieval by you and also continue to be loaned to someone? Obviously not, it's no different with money. But, because cash is fungible, and most people don't withdraw all their money at the same time, banks are able to continue this charade, pretending like your cash is available for withdrawal while simultaneously lent out to someone else. The only time that the charade becomes readily apparent is during financial crises. During crises people get nervous and start demanding their deposits in cash, if everyone should do so (a run on the bank), the bank would not have enough cash on hand to make good on their contractual obligations. The only reason the charade continues is because central banks loan banks more money during crises by printing more money out of thin air (of course, there's no such thing as a free lunch, money printing debases the currency, so anyone who holds cash loses). [1] Estimates vary, but the consensus seems to be that less than 10% of "money" actually exists in printed bills/coins: (a) Estimate 8.3% -- https://www.quora.com/What-percentage-of-the-worlds-money-is-printed-in-cash-bills-coins (b) Estimate 8% -- http://www.howstuffworks.com/currency6.htm
- seivan 11y agoOut of curiosity what would ways to mitigate that? Real Estate appreciation/rent or index funds?
- theheck 11y agoMitigate what, the value of your savings from being debased through money printing? I'll assume that's your question in this response. Unfortunately there isn't a straight-forward answer, everything (precious metals, stock market, bonds, etc.) is more volatile than holding cash, but your cash is guaranteed to go down in value over time due to money printing, so you get screwed if you do nothing. There are too many permutations and personal situations to offer a one-size-fits-all solution, but I'll offer some general guidance. If you're just starting your career, and don't have much to invest, you should just focus on becoming the best in your field, take advantage of any retirement matching that your company offers, and invest it in low-cost broad market index funds (like Vanguard's S&P 500 Index Fund VFINX is one example). Most people who don't have very much money worry about what to do with their money when they would get much better returns just by focusing on improving their skills! If you have money to invest, you should read about value investing, I'd start with The Intelligent Investor by Benjamin Graham. Even if you don't want to manage your own money (and most people shouldn't unless it's going to be their full-time job), it will give you a great foundation for understanding the financial markets and how to evaluate people who you select to manage your money.