3 ms·
Who's the "you" in your question? Humans wouldn't be able to tell; that's the whole point. A computer might "figure out" that it's easier to give us something t
by pavel_lishin 11y ago
Who's the "you" in your question? Humans wouldn't be able to tell; that's the whole point. A computer might "figure out" that it's easier to give us something that looks like what we're looking for instead of what we're actually looking for.
- JadeNB 11y ago> A computer might "figure out" that it's easier to give us something that looks like what we're looking for instead of what we're actually looking for. As a mathematician, that seems like my idea of a dystopia. Shiver. On the other hand, assuming that it doesn't go off and develop sentience on its own, how would a computer figure out such a thing? Assuming that it is programmed in such a way that it only produces correct proofs of (possibly uninteresting) theorems, there'll be no way for it to produce those 'easier' deceptitheorems in order to be rewarded for doing so.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoWell, that's why I put "figure out" in quotes; it would probably be closer to an evolutionary process. Some instance of an algorithm stumbles onto a simple process for generating proofs that it deems okay to submit, and never gets its power yanked for doing so because the algorithm fakes us out.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThe hypothesis class that the ML algorithm works within is proofs, checkable by something like Coq, so that can't actually be done.