3 ms·
What a subverted justification! The FSF people basically masquerade their own personal interests and values to some sort of ethical principle that should be of
by stcredzero 11y ago
What a subverted justification! The FSF people basically masquerade their own personal interests and values to some sort of ethical principle that should be of importance to the whole of society.
Basically, almost all political movements, including most activism, falls prey to this sort of distortion in some subset of its population.
I really like that the FSF exists, and that there is a choice to use Free (Libre) software. I also think it's right and proper for people to try to convince me to use free software. What I don't like, is when convince crosses the line into coerce. A product should live or die by its utility, not by peer pressure and denigration of those who do not use it.
If Apple is bad for using social pressure, arbitrary lock-in, and legal bludgeons to distort the marketplace in its own interests, then so is the FSF when it does the same. How about software and computing that stands on the merits of its utility?
EDIT:
Furthermore, for the purposes of granting usage rights, even if we considered software to be different from physical objects (because software is information and can be replicated at no cost) - then why doesn't the Free software ideology apply equally to other information works: books, music, movies, etc? Why shouldn't all those be Free too? Why should copyright law apply in any different way to software, than to other information works? Someone explain this inconsistency to me...
I like the analogy with overflights.
https://www.ted.com/talks/larry_lessig_says_the_law_is_strangling_creativity https://www.ted.com/talks/larry_lessig_says_the_law_is_stran...
It used to be that property rights extended from the boundaries of someone's land, indefinitely upwards. That used to make sense in the days when flying was an impossibility. But when people first started flying airplanes, that interpretation of property rights would've resulted in every landholder charging every airplane for overflight.
Rights have a pragmatic component, and they change along with technological change. Copyright made sense when copying information had a significant cost. Nowadays, copyright needs to change in the same way property rights changed.