3 ms·
> Well, I do agree that having so many closed computer systems would suck, and open alternatives would be much more preferable. But, FFS, desire is no basis for
by jrochkind1 11y ago
> Well, I do agree that having so many closed computer systems would suck, and open alternatives would be much more preferable. But, FFS, desire is no basis for something being a right, a "freedom".
Well, okay, on terminology. But desire is certainly a basis for taking collective action with others who share your desires, to make your desires so, is it not? And isn't that actually a true freedom, the freedom to take collective action through legal and voluntary means to make your desires so? Which is just what FSF/GNU is doing?
And I say this as someone who actually is NOT really a fan of FSF/GNU restrictive licensing. (Because that's really what it is, "viral" licenses like GNU are actually MORE restrictive than a do-what-you-like MIT-style license. A fact that is probably not controversial; GNU as a license is intentionally more confining towards developers, to try and accomplish FSF/GNU aims which they believe will be less confining for end-users).
I'm actually not a huge fan of FSF/GNU in practice... but the OP's arguments are still silly.