9 ms·
Berlin social housing winning the residential race
- datashovel 11y agoThe way markets boom and bust so frequently these days, one could almost interpret this as unveiling how ludicrous purely free markets can and probably will behave if they're given free reign, in the modern world, to "discover" market value. Instead markets are in many ways indistinguishable from casinos anymore.
- rosege 11y agoyes but markets these days are anything but free - with the fed (and its equivalents around the world) fixing the price of money then doing their Quantitive Easing tricks I would argue that we have a highly manipulated market now. On top of that the bailing out of banks etc also show that the market isnt free.
- datashovel 11y agoVery true. I think I was mostly attempting to point out "Shiny Object Syndrome" and how it applies to financial markets, and how quickly (in today's world) it can reinforce itself given the real-time nature of how information is distributed and consumed. http://impossiblehq.com/shiny-object-syndrome/ http://impossiblehq.com/shiny-object-syndrome/ As soon as all day traders (not just my circle of friends, but every single active investor in the world) get word that the new big trend is going to be real estate in Brisbane Australia, that's where we're going to put our money, which is going to push the price up, which in turn is going to attract additional investors, which is going to push the price up even more, etc.. That is until the market starts to turn. In which case all people who have bought into the real estate market craze in Brisbane Australia (who don't actually live in Brisbane Australia) pull their money out, which in turn causes prices to drop, which in turn causes everyone else to start pulling their money out. Because they all knew it was way over priced. It's not their fault after all. It's not illegal. They were just riding the bull as long as they possibly could. Doesn't matter what kind of devastation they leave behind because they don't live there and won't feel its effects. Oh, and by the way... Now that the Brisbane Australia bubble has popped, I heard the next big thing is going to be tulip bulbs. Great, I'm all in!
- biafra 11y agoPretty much the only way to be kicked out in Berlin is if the owner needs the apartment for themselves (or a close relative) to live in. It is called Eigenbedarf.
- mc32 11y agoThis article covers Berlin. How is it in other cities and states in Germany? Berlin, as far as I know, has a unique history so that it's not always representative of Germany as a whole, in general terms. That's to say, while Berkeley, CA, has some interesting politics, it does not reflect state or national policies. Meaning, what works in Berkeley (or Berlin) may not be transplantable. Meaning that while interesting and worthwhile to study as a way to address housing shortages, it may or may not hold a viable answer for other jurisdictions who don't share some of the reasons making this policy viable under particular circumstances. What's the state of affairs in Hamburg, Essen, Frankfurt, etc.
- lis 11y agoFrom a law perspective the situation is very similar. Tenants can't be evicted easily. In areas of high demand rents are (mostly) indexed as well. Compared to Hamburg, Munich and Dusseldorf Berlin is still rather cheap. I have apartments both in Hamburg and Berlin and pay roughly ~1.5 as much per square meter in Hamburg, though the one in Berlin is in a much better location.
- mironathetin 11y agoMunich here. Most expensive city in Germany in absolute prices and second expensive relative the the average income (Freiburg is top there). 12 Euros per square meter average rent. In good locations, 20 is asked regularly. More than 30 for small 1 bedroom appartements. Statistics says, 3300 Euros per square meter buying price. We try to find a good place since 3 years, and we have never seen anything below 7000 Euros (in good central locations). 10.000+ is asked for regularly. The market is standing still because few people can afford these prices any more. Berlin prices would be a dream come true here. Laws are the same as in Berlin. But since there is much more money to win, there is more aggression to get rid of old tenants and thus raise prices and/or build new houses. We have seen places, where the real estate dealer did not tell us how nice everything is, but calculated how much we can make, if we rent to Engineers who work for big companies like BMW or EADS. In cash and percent interest rate for our investment. Never heard that anywhere before.
- 11y ago
- Tiktaalik 11y agoWhat is the vacancy rate in Berlin? Is it at all possible to actually get your foot in the door and rent a cheap apartment? The typical argument against price controls is that it reduces returns and discourages investment and new development, which can make it extremely difficult to find an apartment. The article didn't touch on this much, but this one line suggested that developers were still happily involved. "...the large institutions that own much of the city’s housing stock are looking for a steady return rather than boom-and-bust cycles..." Of course low vacancies happen in aggressively pro-development cities too. Canada has similar pro-homeownership policies to Australia and Vancouver's real estate market is similarly high priced as Melbourne's. New condos in Vancouver are being developed aggressively and yet the vacancy sits at 0.5%.
- facepalm 11y agoSorry the article is full of nonsense. Rents are rising quickly in Berlin, and the government is not paving way for enough new housing to compensate for the demand. Limits on rents are also a reason why fewer housing is being built. As for the protesters on the street - yes, it happens, but usually they are not successful. It's really weird to see Berlin cited as an example for successful housing policies. It may be so that if you can stay in your flat, you are in a relatively good position. But there are many people moving to Berlin, and people having kids can also not always stay in their old flat. So that policy only helps a few old residents.
- mschuster91 11y ago> It's really weird to see Berlin cited as an example for successful housing policies. Still better than Munich lol. In Berlin you can at least find a run-down shared punker flat or occupied house if you're OK with that, in Munich you're straight outa luck if you aren't best friends with a RE broker. LPT: If you ever have the chance to befriend a broker, do so - it might save your ass in the future.
- facepalm 11y agoThese things exist in Munich, too :-)
- jfoster 11y agoAnd yet the tens of thousands of new investment properties in Sydney and Melbourne that sit empty while waiting for a capital gain – labelled “speculative vacancies” by non-profit lobby group Prosper Australia – or which are rented to tourists at highly inflated rates, indicate that the market is not always a panacea for affordability. Is that not just a glut that hasn't yet taken hold? If there really is over-supply, the investors will eventually end up competing with each other once they try to realize their capital gain. I don't mean to suggest that a growing glut of empty properties ending with a bust is the best way for this to go, but it does seem to me that on a long enough time scale, supply & demand principles will still hold true.
- darkr 11y ago"Empty" doesn't necessarily mean that it still owned by the developer and not yet sold on. It can mean that it has been purchased, but that whoever has purchased it has no use for it other than as an investment. We've had this problem in London for years now, mainly in the west towards Vauxhall and beyond, but there are pockets of it all over, and it doesn't seem to be going away any time soon. Large new tower blocks containing "luxury apartments" are built, purchased by and often marketed solely to foreign investors and offshore companies as a way of parking large amounts of money into what is seen as a relatively safe investment, with several tax loopholes: Unlike many other investments, property in the UK is not subject to capital gains tax, inheritance tax etc. Also, if the property is owned by an offshore company rather than an individual then stamp duty (5% on £675k or more) is not payable. AFAIK this last loophole was closed last year, but only for properties over £2 million (and, I think the tax is only payable on the remainder that exceeds that). As well as adding to an existing under-supply in the market for actual houses in which actual people can live in, the speculative feedback loop caused by this only drives up property prices further.
- mahyarm 11y agoA punitive (%3 ?) long-term unused property tax is the solution to this.
- andor 11y agoBerlin has a housing shortage, and these measures are just workarounds. Before the refugee crisis, a growth of 40.000 people per year was expected, vs. plans to build 10.000 new apartments. The decision against developing the the abandoned Tempelhof airport only makes it worse, and shows some of the social problems in the city. Bear in mind that everybody who got to vote on the referendum already lived in Berlin: "Though about 20 per cent of the development was to be reserved for affordable housing, the locals decided to keep their expansive city oasis free of any new buildings. The rationale was that increased supply often only means more luxury dwellings and does not address affordability." "Luxury" here doesn't mean huge, it just means "well built, nice kitchen, 14 EUR/m^2". It's like saying: "I don't want anybody else to buy a car, because they might get a Mercedes, which I cannot afford." The social housing system is also quite unfair, if you ask me. Social housing apartments are in regular buildings, not separated from the rest. The idea is to counter gentrification, and keep the population mixed. You are only eligible below some margin of income. So far so good, but if you work and earn one Euro too much, you need to pay twice the rent, for the exact same apartment.
- Loque 11y agoWhat source are you using for the housing shortage? I lived there for a while and in my experience this was not the case - interested to learn more. Edit: did some searching: http://www.thelocal.de/20150819/germany-building-homes-in-wrong-places-experts http://www.thelocal.de/20150819/germany-building-homes-in-wr... Quite interesting stuff.
- lispm 11y agoIf the article does not make it clear, in East Germany there are many many cities with a shortage of citizens - not a shortage of houses. http://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article146994158/So-schnell-entvoelkert-Ostdeutschland.html http://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article146994158/So-schnell-en... Five Bundesländer there had the population reduced from 14.5 Million down to 12.5 million...
- tptacek 11y agoWhat's the alternative to mixed-income housing? The US tried segregated low-income housing for decades, and the result was a disaster. The new system, called Section 8, is a privatized voucher system; it doesn't give tenants lower rents, but by subsidizing rents directly, it has the same fairness impact.
- al_chemist 11y agoTwo years ago I moved to Berlin from a different country and it took me 6 months to get my own apartment. Which was pretty good, because I knew someone who was leaving and he vouched for me. Then I understood that I subletted from someone who was subletted from another one who rented from company who rented from owner. Normally you need credit score, letter of recommendation from previous slave-own^Wland lord. Then you can try to rent one. By which I mean you go there with 20 other people and land lord does... casting. They pick the best tenant out of quite big group. Truly, the best way to rent!
- x0rg 11y agoI'm living this nightmare. If people thinks that renting here is easy they're just wrong. Laws are just trying to fix a situation that is about to get much worse.
- hussong 11y agoIt's gotten a lot worse in the past two years, more like 60 people showing up for attractive places and the whole job / income / vouching paperwork dance even for small apartments in the 500 Euro range.
- arbitrage314 11y agoI'm in full support of some housing/rental market regulation, but such regulation is not without its cons. Similar to Berlin, in New York, tenants have very strong rights. For instance, if a tenant stops paying rent, the landlord can't evict that tenant for 6 months. This sounds nice--helping someone in need instead of the greedy landlord--but the overall effect is largely negated (as usual, the market seems to always adjust when you mess with it). It's now MUCH harder to get an apartment in New York in the first place. You need a large income, guarantors, or lots of savings, in addition to credit checks, bank staements, tax statements, etc. I'm pretty sure the same people that the law was meant to help are now unable to rent in the first place. One idea I have is, instead of messing with the free market, create a futures exchange whereby renters and landlords can lock in rent. This market is possible because there are just as many people concerned about rent going up as there are rent going down. If you want to keep renting, but you don't want to hedge yourself via the futures market or via buying a place, you'll just have to accept the risk that you'll be priced out of your neighborhood someday.
- puredemo 11y ago>create a futures exchange whereby renters and landlords can lock in rent. Can't you just sign a longer lease?
- arbitrage314 11y agoGood point. If you're interested in living in the same place continuously, signing a longer lease is perfect. I think a futures exchange is a bit more flexible though because: 1. Longer leases are often not available 2. People often want to move apartments after, e.g., having a baby
- oh_sigh 11y agoConsidering you and the landlord have opposite goals(you want to minimize rent, she wants to maximize it), it is unlikely you would find a situation where long residential leases are offered.
- 11y ago
- arbitrage314 11y agoIf you want rents to go down, you need to incentivize builders to build more property. Some regulation is good, but if there's too much in favor of the tenants, building more property becomes unprofitable, and you're stuck with the same problem.
- duncan_bayne 11y ago> It's like saying: "I don't want anybody else to buy a car, because they might get a Mercedes, which I cannot afford." It's funny how often envy is a motivating factor behind socialism.
- mschuster91 11y ago> And yet the tens of thousands of new investment properties in Sydney and Melbourne that sit empty while waiting for a capital gain – labelled “speculative vacancies” by non-profit lobby group Prosper Australia – or which are rented to tourists at highly inflated rates, indicate that the market is not always a panacea for affordability. Easy solution: for any period longer than 3 months in which the property is not rented with a minimum lease time of 12 months, the owner has to pay a fixed sum per square meter of the property; said sum should be based on the asked rent price.