3 ms·

The tool is really well done and impressive. Yes, it exists to work around gaps in GitHub's functionality, but it's not like we're going to self host git repos

The tool is really well done and impressive. Yes, it exists to work around gaps in GitHub's functionality, but it's not like we're going to self host git repos and use gitolite...

jeffwilcox 11y ago
My hope is that I can delete this in the future. It's a scary place to be in when we're 1) dependent on a third party, 2) we have to follow GitHub and the API down the rabbit whole, and 3) we are just trying to enable our team to get going fast and hope in time GitHub can just give us all the right tools that check at least some boxes we need, i.e. very granular management to delegate decision making even more.
- EvanPlaice 11y ago
  What's so scary about it? Any data that is stored on GitHub (ex issues, PRs) can be pulled down via the REST API. So, it should be relatively easy to build a migration tool or alternate UI if necessary.
cat-dev-null 11y ago
Oh man... reminds me of svn2git migration I did, an integration of gitolite, deploying on-prem AD, jenkins, JIRA, Confluence and all working together a couple years back. Getting the LDAP query just right is 90% of it. These days: - JIRA - for internal, complex project management because the plugins are really good - Confluence - wiki w/ plugins - Asana - Slack/FlowDock - waay better than digging through HipChat/Campfire, IRC - Hubot - integrations/CLI for everything - jenkins - for private CI - Github enterprise - or maybe Gitlab if one can get away with it - Google Apps for Work / Zoho - because of AD integrations PS: When deploying a portal page whether internally or for a client, a bespoke 404 page with either a game or random funny images is the way to go. Maybe a humans.txt too.
- monksy 11y ago
  What about Bitbucket?
  - baudehlo 11y ago
    Bit bucket is great if you are ok with pushes taking 1 minute and webhooks taking 20 minutes. Sadly, wish I was joking. But it happens all too often.

The tool is really well done and impressive. Yes, it exists to work around gaps in GitHub's functionality, but it's not like we're going to self host git repos and use gitolite...

jeffwilcox 11y ago

My hope is that I can delete this in the future. It's a scary place to be in when we're 1) dependent on a third party, 2) we have to follow GitHub and the API down the rabbit whole, and 3) we are just trying to enable our team to get going fast and hope in time GitHub can just give us all the right tools that check at least some boxes we need, i.e. very granular management to delegate decision making even more.

EvanPlaice 11y ago
What's so scary about it? Any data that is stored on GitHub (ex issues, PRs) can be pulled down via the REST API. So, it should be relatively easy to build a migration tool or alternate UI if necessary.

cat-dev-null 11y ago

Oh man... reminds me of svn2git migration I did, an integration of gitolite, deploying on-prem AD, jenkins, JIRA, Confluence and all working together a couple years back. Getting the LDAP query just right is 90% of it. These days: - JIRA - for internal, complex project management because the plugins are really good - Confluence - wiki w/ plugins - Asana - Slack/FlowDock - waay better than digging through HipChat/Campfire, IRC - Hubot - integrations/CLI for everything - jenkins - for private CI - Github enterprise - or maybe Gitlab if one can get away with it - Google Apps for Work / Zoho - because of AD integrations PS: When deploying a portal page whether internally or for a client, a bespoke 404 page with either a game or random funny images is the way to go. Maybe a humans.txt too.

monksy 11y ago
What about Bitbucket?
- baudehlo 11y ago
  Bit bucket is great if you are ok with pushes taking 1 minute and webhooks taking 20 minutes. Sadly, wish I was joking. But it happens all too often.