15 ms·
Of 135 shuttle missions, 2 resulted in the death of all crew, giving a confidence interval of something like 1-4% for the mortality risk of each flight. Any sa
by jessriedel 11y ago
Of 135 shuttle missions, 2 resulted in the death of all crew, giving a confidence interval of something like 1-4% for the mortality risk of each flight. Any sane assessment of the first Apollo landing missions would put the subjective mortality risk at 10% at the very least. (Later landings were somewhat safer, subjectively, since the equipment was proven.)
I can't imagine the in-mission mortality risk of a Mars mission would realistically be less than 5%, and 15% would not be unacceptable to me. A 10% in-mission risk equates to something like 5 years of lost life in expectation.
In comparison to this, the risk of cancer seem small or comparable. Yes, you'll need to provide sufficient shielding to prevent aggressive cancers from probably developing during the mission, or ones that will reliably lead to death before 60. But I'm not at all surprised that we may need to accept a much higher cancer risk than we would for a normal occupation. This doesn't strike me as one of the key challenges.
- patio11 11y agoI can't imagine the in-mission mortality risk of a Mars mission would realistically be less than 5%, and 15% would not be unacceptable to me. Thus the rationalist Mars mission: send a drone to Mars. Give your five favorite NASA crew members one shot in the head apiece with a fairly spun six shot pistol with one bullet chambered. This accomplishes all of your objectives, is cheaper, and minimizes the danger that the mission architects are underestimating the risk.
- smeyer 11y agoThe general claim is that your argument is flawed in "this accomplishes all of your objectives". I don't claim to be an expert in the field, but I've heard people who do care about and practice planetary and martian science that a manned mission could accomplish more than all the previous unmanned missions combined.
- nabla9 11y agoThat could be true and manned mission can still be irrational choice. All manned missions arguments I have seen are somewhat coy in this respect. Yes, geologist can make better choices on spot and take better samples than current drones, but that's not real comparison. We should compare alternative strategies using opportunity cost. The money used for manned mission could be used for massive fleet of of drones, satellites and technical development. Missions could be more incremental and cover more areas. Self driving cars are just taking off on earth. How does advance fleet of Mars robocars and satellites mapping Mars compare to manned mission?
- mapt 11y agoSome of the lectures I've seen actually peg this as true, but for the wrong reason. It is possible to put together automated missions at-scale. But not likely. Because auditors can trim back an automated mission's scope smoothly, no matter how expansive it is, in order to save money. A slightly lighter, cheaper camera, gives way to an even more slightly lighter, cheaper camera, ad infinitum. A hundred units give way to 99 units give way to 30 units give way to 1 unit. But if you try to do that with a manned mission, you start to jeopardize the public heroes you have sensationalized in order to fund the mission. You don't get to send half a human being to Mars.
- brianberns 11y agoWe've already sent a number of drones to Mars. There are rational reasons for wanting to send humans as well: Humans can do things on Mars that drones cannot, and they pave the way for possible colonization in the future.
- _fizz_buzz_ 11y ago> Humans can do things on Mars that drones cannot Such as? The only thing I can think of is that they can test if the human body can endure life on Mars. Honestly, as cool as sending people to mars is, I don't think it is an idea driven by rationality at this point.
- dinosammy 11y agoHumans on mars would inspire future generations with dreams of space travel, which will make them more likely to support higher levels of NASA funding?
- jcranmer 11y agoYou mean like how landing on the moon did wonders for NASA's budget?
- Fiahil 11y ago>> Humans can do things on Mars that drones cannot > Such as? Growing potatoes?
- 11y ago
- hoorayimhelping 11y agoBut it completely ignores the main reason we do this: because we're humans and we're not rational. We have irrational emotions, and we think symbolically. Sending a human to Mars and bringing them back is way less about actually going to Mars and back and way more about humanity making sure we can still beat challenges that face us.
- analyst74 11y agowith the speed of robotics advancement, compared to advancement in material science and human preservation technologies, we actually might have a team of base-building Martian robots before being able to send astronauts there.
- hfourm 11y agoThis probably makes the most sense. I still see sending a human to Mars as a likely precursor though. If we prove it is possible, alongside the advancements that come from the missions, would hopefully dramatically increase NASA fandom and funding.
- frandroid 11y agoMaybe a drone can build Starfighter too...
- jessriedel 11y ago"Rational" is not a property of ends, it is a property of means (and beliefs). All ends are arbitrary. The robots sent to mars are not useful for any reasonable economic reason. Even insofar as you count speculative basic research as economically useful, there are vastly better ways to spend that money on speculative basic research on Earth. So why go to Mars? Because either (1) you find the basic research being done about Martian geology particularly compelling or (2) you want to see it explored by humans for its own sake. If you really actually believe in (1), then by all means; send more robots. But I'll bet 100:1 that you personally have no appreciation for the basic science questions, which are mostly very technical and boring. (Hint: grand-seeming questions about life are promoted for publicity and funding reasons, but these are not the ones that actually drive the science, and we are not learning more about the origin of life from going to Mars.) Rather, I think you'll have to admit we want to go to Mars because it is awesome. You may think sending metal under our control is just as awesome as sending flesh and blood humans, but ultimately this is an aesthetic judgement which is not grounded in rationality. Personally, I would like to see humans walk there, and I'm happy to pay my citizen-share of $100/year over the next decade to make it happen.
- taurath 11y agoI think you should work on quantifying the power of "awesome" in terms of increased planetwide hopefulness and collaboration. Optimism itself is a very powerful and meaningful thing to achieve. Pretending "aesthetics" don't matter and our hardware isn't very significantly designed to respond to emotion is a huge flaw in "purely logical" reasoning. For goodness sake didn't we already cover this in Star Trek TNG?
- jacquesm 11y agoI'd happily invest in SpaceX if they let me. Even if it counts as 'wasted' money in the books of some the simple fact that humanity would aspire to walking on another planet is worth backing. Robot exploration just doesn't feel the same to me. Hearing a 'roger' beep still gives me the willies and I was only 4 when the moonlandings happened. Nothing we did after that was as impressive to me, even though I'm sure it was easier to impress my 4 year old self than it will be to impress me today, walking on Mars would certainly qualify.
- jaredhansen 11y ago>this accomplishes all of your objectives No, it doesn't. It doesn't at all! Establishing human presence on Mars is one of the core objectives of the whole program. It's one of the reasons we care about Mars. Hell, moving gradually toward making additional homes for human beings is part of why we do space exploration in general. Yes, you can gather rocks via robots and send back data and whatever else, but to claim that doing so exhausts the set of reasonable objectives for Mars missions is just silly. Here's a thought experiment to confirm: How many probes have we flown to how many planets in the solar system? Any idea, roughly, when the first one happened, or the last? You may know, but most folks have no idea. Conversely: where in the solar system have humans been? Any idea when we first got there, or when the last trip was? Unlike all the many highly valuable probe missions we've sent, here, most people actually know something about it. This is because people care about other people and their experiences, in a way that they don't care about scientific results as such. Putting human beings on other worlds is an end in itself, and it is simply not accomplished by sending drones instead.
- kens 11y agoIn comparison, the risk of death climbing Mount Everest is in the 1.5% to 10% range (depending on how you count), and this is something people do for fun. Obviously safe space flight is a good thing, but I think it's reasonable to accept that going to Mars is considerably more dangerous than climbing Everest.
- prodmerc 11y agoYeah, this is what I don't get. People do drugs, skydive, go sailing and do 150 MPH on motorcycles for fun, but they can lose their shit if 1 in 100 dies going anywhere in space... I guess it will change with time...
- anigbrowl 11y agoBecause the costs of putting people in space are huge, so you need correspondingly huge buy-in. Dangerous recreational activities only appeal to a tiny minority of people (while quite a lot of people take drugs recreationally, most do so fairly cautiously rather than in heroic quantities or contexts a la Hunter S Thompson). With space travel, it's both expensive and inaccessible other than to those who could be regarded as among the 'best and the brightest,' and whose loss is felt disproportionately. A better contrast might be that we (in the US) have a moderately high tolerance for deaths in war, because the bar for entry into military service is not so high. But if you recall the early days of the war in Afghanistan, there was a big freakout over the death of Corporal Pat Tillman, who abandoned a promising career as an NFL quarterback to serve his country post 9/11 and then died in a friendly fire situation during combat. It's very hard to become quarterback in the NFL so his death was considered a great loss, even though morally it's no different from the deaths of thousands of other soldiers. So deaths on a Mars mission would provoke a reaction of 'why are we sending our best to die in the cold wastes of space/on the surface of distant planets when we have perfectly serviceable robots?' I think the way it will change is if privately financed asteroid mining becomes a practical reality, in which case deaths in the line of work will be considered tragic but acceptable (within reason), much like deaths on oil rigs and other high-risk industrial environments.
- 11y ago
- hguant 11y agoArmstrong has said he thought he and Aldrin had about a 50% chance of success for the moon landing. Failure could mean lots of things outside of situations resulting in death, but still, they were taking an awe full risk. Also, looking at the manned Apollo missions, one out of 12 resulted in the death of the crew (Apollo 1), and one in 6 missions were failures (Apollo 1 and 13). Space flight was a hugely risky endeavor back then.
- VLM 11y agoSomething carefully avoided in the journalist article, yet relevant, is a vaguely four year mission would naturally have a fatality rate around mission length divided by average human lifespan so a death rate around 5% would be somewhat normal. You take a vacation of 1/20th your lifespan, 1/20th of you will die. Before the screaming starts, I am well aware this off the cuff estimate is not the pinnacle of modern actuarial science, and there are a zillion mitigating factors likely to lead to lower fatality rates. I would be kind of pissed off at having to spend 1/20th of my lifetime mostly on a commute to a vacation, I would better tolerate spending maybe 1/40th of my life immigrating permanently somewhere. Also roughly 1/2 the cancer risk would be nice. How much stuff you'd have to send to make it permanent vs merely 1/20th of a lifespan is somewhat unclear.
- WalterBright 11y agoGiven the long travel times, the untried machinery, the unknown risks, the known risks, the isolation, I doubt the chances of getting there would be larger than 10%, and returning about 0%. One possibility might be to send older people, or people with a short life expectancy on earth, with the idea they could do something great with their remaining time. This may be politically impossible, though.
- rm445 11y agoGiven the small number of crew needed for an initial programme of missions, it ought to be possible to select from the population of the Earth a number of superbly able and healthy people who simply accept the risk. I sometimes suspect that the proposers of sending older people to Mars are getting on a bit themselves and wish for a spot they otherwise would be denied. (Nothing personal Mr Bright, I'm sure you'd be an admirable astronaut and I'd happily launch with you if we were given the chance). You don't need to select crew from a subset for whom the calculus of risk of death versus ongoing life on Earth is different in some way. You just need crew who are willing to take the risks, whatever their reasons.
- WalterBright 11y agoNASA selects superbly fit people because they can. I don't see the crises one is likely to encounter in space are ones that superb fitness is going to help much. There's no way I'm going in a tin can to Mars :-) so that's not my motivation. I'm sure there are many young people who would be willing to go on a one way ride to Mars and certain death. I suspect that would be politically impossible, though.
- WalterBright 11y agoI'm sure there are many people who want to launch me on a one way trip to Mars!
- simonh 11y agoMost if the machinery could be tried on the moon first. If we adopt a Mars Direct approach, a return vessel with in-situ refuelling capability would arrive and recommissioning itself before the crew even left Earth, and we might even trial the return vehicle in an automated there-and-back mission first. With all these factors, I think the chances of success could probably be improved to perhaps 90% arrival and 70% return. Pure guesses though, of course.