4 ms·
Very bad title: it implicitly equates "Good Doctors" with "famous doctors" rather than with "doctors whose actions benefit patients". The real point of the arti
by pdonis 11y ago
Very bad title: it implicitly equates "Good Doctors" with "famous doctors" rather than with "doctors whose actions benefit patients". The real point of the article is that one should ask questions and be personally involved in care decisions, rather than just taking the doctor's word. But the linkbait headline obfuscates that point.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gdulli 11y agoThe article uses "best" and "senior" as well, more often than "famous", and explains that the data refers to times when "the senior cardiologists were out of town" (anyone attending conventions, for example.) It's unlikely there are enough "famous" cardiologists alone to have accounted for "tens of thousands" of admissions. If so, the meaning of "famous" is downgraded to those who are sufficiently senior, rather than how we usually think of "famous."
- pdonis 11y ago> The article uses "best" and "senior" as well, more often than "famous" Yes, you're right, "famous" is too narrow, "senior" would be a better term.
- JamesBarney 11y agoHmm, I think I disagree. It was pretty obvious to me that when they used the term "good doctor" they meant better by some objective criteria that many people use as a proxy for "doctor whose actions benefit patients". If "good doctor" had meant "doctor whose actions benefit patients" it would be a contradiction that most would-be readers could dismiss.
- pdonis 11y ago> It was pretty obvious to me that when they used the term "good doctor" they meant better by some objective criteria that many people use as a proxy for "doctor whose actions benefit patients". But those doctors aren't better by those objective criteria [1]; that's the whole point. Their patients do worse, on average, by objective criteria. So they aren't "good doctors" in the sense that patients care about. They are only "good doctors" if you equate "good doctors" with "senior doctors" or something like that (as gdulli pointed out upthread, "famous", the term I used in my OP in this thread, is too narrow)--something which does not include the objective criteria about actual patient outcomes. [1] At least, that's what the article is claiming. As others in this subthread have pointed out, there is other data that should be looked at to see how valid the claim actually is.
- JamesBarney 11y agoThe objective criteria that the study uses to separate doctors into "good"(as it is used in the title) and bad was "goes to cardiologist conferences". The good doctor the title refers to is one that attends a cardiologist conference.
- pdonis 11y ago> The good doctor the title refers to is one that attends a cardiologist conference. And this is supposed to be the "objective criteria" that, in your words, many people use as a proxy for "doctor whose actions benefit patients"? That makes no sense to me; I doubt most people even know what conferences, if any, their cardiologist (or any other doctor) goes to. Nor do I see the article claiming that "attending conferences" is an objective criterion that patients use.
- nonbel 11y agoThe authors suggest it is due to a reduced number of unnecessary treatments: >"Our results echo paradoxical findings documented during a labor strike by Israeli physicians in 2000, in which hundreds of thousands of outpatient visits and elective surgical procedures were cancelled, but by many accounts mortality rates dramatically fell during the year.27 Similar reports of decreased mortality during physician labor strikes exist elsewhere, with most hypotheses attributing mortality declines to lower rates of nonurgent surgical procedures.28" http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=2038979 http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=20389... However, they do not seem to consider that mortality rates are seasonal and so are the meeting dates. The seasonality differs for different causes of death. A quick search came up with this for heart-related causes, so for example: >"When grouped by season, we observed the distribution of the 449 coronary heart disease fatalities to show a relative peak in winter (32%) and relative nadir in spring (21%)." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3756551/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3756551/ What they should have done is plot mortality by week so we can see if there is a sudden dip around the conference dates.
- pdonis 11y ago> What they should have done is plot mortality by week so we can see if there is a sudden dip around the conference dates. Agreed, this would be a better test of what they are claiming.
- nonbel 11y agoThe day of week probably matters as well. For example, the conferences will always span a weekend, giving a biased sample of days. I think it is a mistake to try interpreting this data without considering it as a timeseries.